KETO
KETO
MEAL PLAN
FREE PRINTABLE: LOW CARB & KETO FOOD LIST!
Join 200,000+ others to get a FREE keto food list, plus weekly keto recipes!
GET IT NOWThis post may contain affiliate links, which help keep this content free. (Full disclosure)
A few weeks ago I posted a keto low carb cream cheese frosting recipe, and mentioned that I had plans to use it more. And, I love that I got recipe requests for ways to use it! Well, you guys are totally my people, because many of you asked for the exact recipe I was planning. Low carb keto sugar-free carrot cake with almond flour! Yay!
With spring just around the corner, it’s the perfect time to start thinking about how to make sugar-free carrot cake. It makes such a wonderful spring dessert!
Granted, it doesn’t exactly feel like spring with the foot of snow (!!) we got last week. But I know the Midwest by now. We can easily go from arctic tundra to heat wave in a matter of days.
So, whether it’s still cold where you live or already starting to warm up, pin or bookmark this keto carrot cake recipe. It will come in handy soon.
It’s good enough to share with the whole family, even if they aren’t low carb. Try it for Easter, Passover, Mother’s Day, or any birthday coming up!
Low Carb Carrot Cake with Almond Flour
You probably know by now that I try to accommodate a variety of diets here at Wholesome Yum. The entire site is low carb and gluten-free, but I also have sections for special dietary requirements in the low carb recipes index.
Choosing a low carb flour for this keto carrot cake was a little challenging. Even though I love almond flour, I know many people have nut allergies, so I attempted with coconut flour.
But, almond flour carrot cake just turned out so much better, I had to go with that. If you can’t have almond flour, you might be able to get away with using ground sunflower seed meal instead. Of course you’d also have to skip the pecans if you have a nut allergy.
If you don’t have an allergy-related reason not to, I highly recommend making this low carb carrot cake with almond flour. It turned out so moist and flavorful! I served it for guests and they kept asking if I was sure that it had no wheat flour or sugar in it.
For those that are keto, you may be wondering how there could possibly be a keto carrot cake. Yes, it’s true that carrots contain more carbs than many other vegetables.
Still, a sugar-free carrot cake can work for a keto diet if it works for your macro requirements. A slice has 5.5 grams net carbs, so it’s totally doable!
I used a tiny bit of blackstrap molasses in this low carb carrot cake. It’s there for flavor, not sweetness, and does not add a significant amount of carbs per serving. But, if this is problematic, feel free to skip it. That is why it was listed as an optional ingredient.
Dairy-Free & Paleo Options for Gluten-Free Carrot Cake
Since we are talking about special diets, I’d like to give some dairy-free and paleo options for this sugar-free carrot cake recipe. In my opinion they are not quite as good as the original version with dairy, but pretty close!
I’ll share my modifications if you want to know how to make paleo gluten-free carrot cake with almond flour.
If you are able to tolerate grass-fed butter, I recommend leaving that as is. It provides the best flavor, and creaming the butter with sweetener creates air pockets. You can still do this with coconut oil, but I like the result best with butter.
But if butter is not an option, using ghee or coconut instead will work! There is just a slight difference in texture and flavor of the end result.
Since erythritol is a natural sweetener, I feel comfortable using it in paleo recipes. That being said, I know some people would rather not. Feel free to replace it with coconut sugar instead. Here is a conversion chart.
Finally, there is the cream cheese frosting for low carb carrot cake. The version I make is neither dairy-free nor paleo, but you can easily swap it with any frosting you like.
I don’t have a paleo one yet, but have heard that some people make it with whipped coconut cream. You can also omit it, too!
How To Make Sugar-Free Carrot Cake
Okay, are you ready to see how to make sugar-free carrot cake with almond flour? Don’t be put off by the number of steps. They are all straightforward!
You might be wondering about the number of ingredients. Isn’t it more than ten? Well, I have a couple of optional ingredients, which I don’t include since they are up to you. The frosting is also considered its own “ingredient”, which is what I always do when using one recipe in another.
I know that’s a bit of a stretch, but I hope you won’t get caught up on the ingredient count. This keto carrot cake recipe was too good not to share!
To start, preheat the oven to 350 degrees Fahrenhei. Line two cake pans with parchment paper, then grease the bottom and sides. I like to use springform pans for easy release, but whatever you have is fine.
Cream together the butter and erythritol, then beat in the remaining wet ingredients. These include molasses, vanilla extract, pineapple extract, and finally eggs, one at a time.
Pineapple extract is optional because it might be a little harder to find, but if you can get it, it’s so good! I included it because many traditional carrot cake recipes include crushed pineapple, and this was a great way to get the same flavor.
Mix together the dry ingredients in another bowl – almond flour, baking powder, cinnamon, and sea salt. Make sure you use finely ground blanched almond flour, not almond meal, for the right texture.
Stir the wet and dry ingredients together, then add the grated carrots and pecans.
Make sure the carrots are just loosely packed when measuring, don’t cram them into the measuring cup or you’ll end up with too much. You don’t really need to drain them, but if they are very wet and oozing water, give them a squeeze first.
You don’t want to get rid of all the moisture, though. The carrots help keep the batter moist. For this reason, pre-shredded carrots are not recommended. Grate them yourself right before using, so that they are somewhat wet.
Transfer the batter to the prepared pans, and bake until the top springs back. You can also use a toothpick to test for doneness.
Final Touches for Keto Carrot Cake
Let the layers of low carb carrot cake cool completely before frosting. I usually cool them in the pan for ten minutes, then a wire rack afterward.
What about the cream cheese frosting? You can make it anytime using this recipe. Don’t forget that you’ll need to double it to have enough for the cake! If you happen to have any leftover, try it on this chocolate mug cake – so good!
It’s fine to store the frosting ahead in the fridge, or just make it while the keto carrot cake bakes or cools. It only takes a few minutes.
Make sure it’s at room temperature before frosting your low carb carrot cake. Otherwise, it will be difficult to spread. You can always thin it out with a little cream if needed.
When the cake layers are completely cool, you can frost one of them. Stack the other one on top, then frost again. Top with more crunchy pecans. Yum, yum!
If you’re not ready to serve your sugar-free carrot cake right away – and if you can resist! – go ahead and refrigerate it. Gently cover it to avoid absorbing odors in the fridge. It’s best within a day or two, but may last up to a week.
Tools To Make Keto Carrot Cake:
Click the links below to see the items used to make this recipe.
- 9″ Springform Pan – This carrot cake is a lot easier to remove when using a springform pan. This is a perfect size for this cake and my cheesecake recipes.
- Box Grater – If you don’t have a food processor, then this is a must have! A box grater is perfect for grating carrots, cheese, cauliflower, and broccoli.
- Pineapple Extract – Real pineapple is higher in carbs and not always a great option in recipes. This extract is lovely and adds the perfect amount of tropical flavor to make this Sugar-Free Carrot Cake shine.
Low Carb Keto Sugar-Free Carrot Cake Recipe with Almond Flour:
Pin it to save for later!
Reader Favorite Recipes
The recipe card is below! Readers also made these similar recipes after making this one.
RECIPE CARD
Go Ad-Free
Low Carb Keto Sugar-Free Carrot Cake Recipe with Almond Flour
Recipe Video
Click or tap on the image below to play the video. It's the easiest way to learn how to make this recipe!
PrintIngredients
Click underlined ingredients to see where to get them.
Please ensure Safari reader mode is OFF to view ingredients.
Get Keto Sweetener For This Recipe
Meet Besti Monk Fruit Allulose Blend, the keto sweetener that tastes, bakes, dissolves, and browns just like sugar, with NO aftertaste and 0 net carbs.
GET BESTIInstructions
Get RECIPE TIPS in the post above, nutrition info + recipe notes below!
Click on the times in the instructions below to start a kitchen timer while you cook.
-
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees F (177 degrees C). Line two 9 in (23 cm) round cake pans with parchment paper. (Use springform pans if you have them.) Grease the bottom and sides.
- In a large bowl, cream together the butter and erythritol, until fluffy. Beat in the molasses (if using), vanilla extract, and pineapple extract (if using). Beat in the eggs, one at a time. Set aside.
- In another bowl, mix together the almond flour, baking powder, cinnamon, and sea salt. Stir the dry ingredients into the bowl with the wet ingredients.
-
Stir in the grated carrots. Fold 1 cup (99 g) of the chopped pecans, reserving the remaining 1/2 cup (48.5 g).
-
Transfer the batter evenly among the two prepared baking pans. Bake for 30-35 minutes, until the top is spring-y.
-
Let the cakes cool in the pans for 10 minutes, then transfer to a wire rack to cool completely.
- Meanwhile, make the sugar-free frosting according to the instructions here. (Double the recipe by entering "12" into the box for # of servings on that page.)
- When the cake has cooled to room temperature, place the bottom layer on a plate or cake stand. Frost, then add the top layer and frost again. Top with the remaining chopped pecans.
Readers Also Made These Similar Recipes
Made this? Leave a rating!
Share your recipe picture with @wholesomeyum or #wholesomeyum on Instagram or in our Facebook support group, too - I'd love to see it!
Recipe Notes
Nutrition info includes the frosting, based on this sugar-free cream cheese frosting recipe.
Serving size: 1 slice, or 1/16 of entire recipe
Video Showing How To Make Low Carb Sugar-Free Carrot Cake:
Don't miss the VIDEO above - it's the easiest way to learn how to make Low Carb Sugar-Free Carrot Cake!
Want some moral support or recipe help?
Nutrition Information Per Serving
Where does nutrition info come from? Nutrition facts are provided as a courtesy, sourced from the USDA Food Database. You can find individual ingredient carb counts we use in the Low Carb & Keto Food List. Net carb count excludes fiber, erythritol, and allulose, because these do not affect blood sugar in most people. (Learn about net carbs here.) We try to be accurate, but feel free to make your own calculations.
Want to save this recipe?
Create a free account to save your favourites recipes and articles!
Sign Up To Save RecipesMore Low Carb Resources
If you want to know more about how to start a low carb diet, want to substitute sweeteners, need a food list, or need support, check these guides:
How To Start Keto 
Keto Sweetener Guide 
Macro Calculator 
Keto Food List Printable
© Copyright Maya Krampf for Wholesome Yum. Please DO NOT SCREENSHOT OR COPY/PASTE recipes to social media or websites. We'd LOVE for you to share a link with photo instead. 🙂
Shop My Must-Have Keto Ingredients
Use the buttons below to buy my new Besti sweeteners and Wholesome Yum keto ingredients, developed by me personally!
Get the full low carb pantry shopping list, browse low carb product discounts, and visit my Amazon Shop!
312 Comments
cary
excellent cake…. will be making it often…. frosting was also good. I kept the 2 t of cinnamon..but had no pineapple extract. I make 14 cupcakes and filled them full as it doesnt rise much… Moist, light, crunchy nuts… yum
Allison
Hello, I’ve been baking a carrot cake which has been our family for many years which everyone loves, but now working on a more healthier & delicious version.
Can vegetable or canola be oil be used with your recipe instead of butter?
Thanking you in advance for your response.
Sincerely,
Allison
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Allison, I don’t recommend using highly processed vegetable or seed oils. The best substitute for the butter in the recipe is actually coconut oil. I hope this helps!
Danielle Meverden
I have gestational diabetes so I have to do low carb. This cake makes mom and baby happy, very happy. I would make it again
Ryan
Can I swap for regular wheat flour? Thank you!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Ryan, Sorry, I don’t think that would work in this recipe. Wheat flour behaves differently from almond flour, so the recipe would need to be reworked to accommodate using wheat flour.
Elsa Butterfield
I used with carrots and apples, wonderful
Patricia
This is a really delicious recipe. Thanks for sharing it!
Kathy Peters
Awesome! I made these tonight for my husband’s birthday, his favorite cake is carrot. I have Celiac and we both stay low carb, so keto recipes keep me gluten free and low carb. After reading the comments, I decided to make these as cupcakes. I left out the pineapple extract and molasses. I added about 1/4 tsp of nutmeg and took the suggestion of adding 1/2 tsp of xanthan gum and 1/2 tsp of baking soda since that works well with gluten free baking. The batter was thick, but carrot cake usually is. I filled the cups to the top since I know gluten free things don’t rise much. This made about 16 cupcakes. We tried a couple while they were still warm and before icing them. They are fantastic! I’ve made several recipes from this site, and they have all been great. I plan to try your German Chocolate Zucchini cake in June for my birthday!
Squeaky
I made half the recipe and the icing, and it made 9 cupcakes for me. They took about 23 minutes to bake. They are very nice! I might add more spice next time, the regular carrot cupcakes I make for the non keto people also has ginger, nutmeg and cloves. They are nice with or without the cream cheese icing, but the icing is so simple and tastes nice.
Andrea
Hello,
If I want to make the carrot cake in 6” pans, how much time in the oven do you recommend? And approx how many pans would yield the entire recipe?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Andrea, You will likely yield 4 layers from a 6″ baking pan. The oven temp will remain the same, but the bake time will decrease. I would start checking for doneness around the 20 minute mark.
Andrea
Thank you very much. I will be posting the final result here in the comments.
TINA BOYD
Loved this cake. It’s the first cake I’ve made since deciding to reduce the white flour and sugar in my life. I was a professional baker prior to this and I must say this cake is as good, or even better, than cakes I made that weren’t keto.
I made a couple of alterations
1. added 1 overripe banana
2. added 1 cup coconut (should have been 1/2 cup)
3. Added 1/2 t ginger, nutmeg, and a sprinkle of clove, reduced cinnamon to 1 t
4. I used a different icing recipe
5. Used 1/4 t pineapple oil (reduced in amount) as I had no pineapple extract
6. Used the coconut sugar instead of erythritol since my daughter doesn’t care for the flavor of erythritol.
Things I wish I’d done differently
1. Used the parchment paper in my pan. The cake stuck and broke apart when removing (part of that I attribute to using too much coconut – see above)
2. Doubled the pineapple oil I used
3. Used the molasses. I think it would have added the extra special something something
4. Kept the full amount of cinnamon, doubled the other spices.
Of note, the coconut sugar does not appear to cream as well as erythritol might.
RM
Made this today. Turned out very good. However, the cream cheese frosting turned out salty because of the cream cheese. Any one have any suggestions on what type of cheese would be a good substitute that is not so salty?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi RM, Did you use salted or unsalted butter? Using unsalted would likely make a big difference if you were sensitive to the salty flavor.
Elizabeth Rosado
Hi, I have a question. Can I substitute the molasses for something else?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Elizabeth, Feel free to omit the molasses if you don’t have it/want to use it. The recipe will still turn out great! Enjoy!
Karen
I left out the molasses and pineapple extract and this was the best carrot cake I have ever tasted.
I also upped the cinnamon (as there is no such thing as too much cinnamon).
Patricia Sullivan
I used Lakanto monk fruit sugar because that is what I had. I only used 1/2 cup because I didn’t want it to be too sweet. My first try at making powdered sugar and I now know that I should have ground it a bit longer. Frosting he as a bit if a grainy texture but still very good. I used large baking cups and they look lovely! I had to watch the time and kept adding time. Went from 25 to 35 minutes. Did I mention that the cups were large. Overall, it was a success. My husband is ore diabetic and this works well for him. It is his birthday today and he is having one of his favorite desserts, so for this we both thank you. If you have any dark chocolate recipes let me know. Many thanks.
Patty
Can I sub monkfruit sugar and how much? Sorry if I didn’t see a previous response, I went through a bunch but didn’t see it.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Patty, Do you mean monk fruit erythritol blend or pure monk fruit? Pure monk fruit is highly concentrated and comes in a small jar. It is usually dark brown in color and in powdered form. Pure monk fruit is not recommended for this recipe. Monk fruit erythritol blend will work fine, but you will need less than what the recipe calls for. When using monk fruit erythritol you will need 1/2 cup + 1 Tablespoon. Enjoy your cake!
Bunny
This is absolutely the very worst keto recipe I’ve ever made. We threw the whole thing out. It was terrible. I’m really sorry but I’d hate to have anyone else waste the ingredients and time to make this.
It was a huge disappointment. It was for my husband’s birthBunnyday.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Bunny, Sorry this recipe didn’t turn out as expected. I would be happy to help you troubleshoot if you could provide more information. Did it not turn out or did it not suit your personal tastes?
Nancy
Reading the recipe and great reviews I would like to try this cake but I avoid dairy for health reasons. Do you think I could sub avocado oil or olive oil? I like your idea for coconut cream for the frosting.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Nancy, If you want to replace the butter with something dairy-free, I recommend coconut oil. You’d also need a dairy-free cream cheese for the frosting.
Jackie
Delicious!
C. Tebo
I did a sheet cake and it turned out like “bars”. They were tasteful bars but was in mood for very moist cake that melts in your mouth. My husband loved it and said better the next day. He put whipped cream on top.
Kim
Can’t wait to try this cake
Since i don’t have or use pineapple extract
And i’ m ok with it being more paleo than keto could i use crushed pineapples and if so how much would you recommend ??
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Kim, This recipe would be too wet if you added crushed pineapple to it. If you don’t have pineapple extract, feel free to omit it. The cake will still be delicious.
Susi
I made this with 4” springform pans so we could control the portions better, but it seemed to take a very long time because the bottom was still so wet. Do you have any recommendations? How full would you think the pans should be, as maybe I filled them too full? Otherwise, this is the best carrot cake and cream cheese frosting recipe ever!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Susi, If you are using 2″ tall (4″ diameter) springform pans, then you will want the pans to be 1/2 full.
Aaron Johnston
Anyone use the metric version of this recipe run into any problems with grams? I am in the UK and would like to make this.
sonia
absolutely amazing! couldn’t tell the difference between normal and this version. If anything this one was way nicer cos you could taste all the flavors as opposed to just sugar!
Squeaky
Yes! The carrot conversion from cups to grams yields way to much carrot! I halved the recipe and stopped at about 120g, because it seemed like an awful lot. That was also 1 large carrot, so I figured that was a good place to stop. Came out nicely though. I might have another little slice right now…..
Shanthi
Cake turned out really yummy. Just the right amount of moisture! I have a Breville mini oven, so baked it at 325 Deg F for 30 min.
I tried this recipe with beets (1 cup) and zucchini (1/2 cup) instead of carrots. Also, used 1/4 cup yoghurt, 1/4 cup coconut oil and 1/4 cup butter. Reduced the amount of pecans as I didn’t have much left at home. I skipped the frosting though.
Sharon Harvey
If I make it into cupcakes instead how long would it cook. The recipe sounds yummy.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Sharon, Start checking for doneness around 22 minutes.
Squeaky
I just made this in to 9 cupcakes with a half recipe. Was still like soup at 20 minutes but were nicely done at a little over 25 minutes.
Selcen
Can i just use ground almonds? Thanks
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Selcen, That’s not recommeded. Finely ground almond flour is best for this recipe.
Sandy
Can the same recipe be used to make cupcakes/muffins?
Would it make more than 12?
Thank you. Can’t wait to try this!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Sandy, Yes, you can make muffins with this batter. I’d start checking after 22 min and every few min after until a toothpick comes out clean. I see other readers comment that they get around 18 muffins.
Charissa
Excellent 5 star recipe. I made this as per the instructions for Diwali. I used a donut shaped cake tray in one batch did not divide in two trays, so it took a further 20mins to cook, I took it out when a knife stuck in the deepest part of the cake came out clean. Lovely recipe, decorated with the frosted icing on this website and whole pecans. The cake was very moist and delicious. My husband loved it soo much. Will be making this again soon!
Melissa
Absolutely delicious.
terry
I just made this recipe for Halloween a few days ago. It was the best carrot cake I have ever eaten! My family was amazed that it was even keto. I even took some to a few co-workers and they told me they almost felt guilty for indulging in it. I assured them they had nothing to worry about. The only thing I added to the recipe was 2 tsp of ground ginger and 1 tsp of nutmeg. Since it was halloween I wanted to give it a little autumn kick. I am not a fan of any pumpkin anything, and this hit the spot. I am definalty making this again and again. Thank you so much!
Kelly
Hi,
How should I change the ingredients in the recipe if I want to make a sheet cake in say a 13×15 pan instead? Thanks.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Kelly, If you change the servings to 24 it should cover your 13×15 inch pan.
Val
Wowee! This is the best carrot cake I have ever tasted, I love it. It is very light and so easy to make. The frosting is great. Not heavy cream cheese frosting that you might come across which doesn’t appeal to me. I added extra heavy cream and it was delightful. I can’t wait to share it with my friends and family. As soon as it had cooled enough for frosting I had to have a slice. Oh! Boy! I couldn’t stop there so had another…… very naughty but worth it. Thank you so much for sharing.
Caroline
Hi, what an absolutely lovely cake. My husband and I loved it and I’ll definitely be making it again, my only problem is that there is no way it would serve 16 people because eating only 1 piece is near on impossible. Be warned, once you start you won’t stop. 🙂
Ann Wilson
I’d like to start off by saying that nothing good can come of this recipe if I make it regularly, simply because I almost ate the whole batch by myself! Yet again you have solidified my reasons to maintain my Keto way of eating. Thank you, thank you, thank you, for another guiltless pleasure to add to my baking favorites!
Alyssia Telfer
This cake is FABULOUS!! Carrot is my brother’s favourite and he’s very critical of most.. HE LOVES THIS CAKE and he was surprised when I told him it’s keto!!
Ruby
Smells and taste wonderful. So glad i found this recipe. I might have overbeaten the batter coz the edges of my cake is a bit crumbly. Will surely make this recipe again. Thanks.
Jacques
Hello, can I add crushed pineapple to the recipe? How would I have to adjust the ingredients?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Jacques, You’d need to make other changes to add pineapple, it would make the cake too wet. I have pineapple extract in the recipe for this very reason and recommend using that.
Adrienne
Made for my husband’s birthday, turned out amazing. Non keto family and neighbors enjoyed it greatly as well. Definitely a keeper.
Susie
Hi,
I can I used Allulose Crystallized or the Allulose powered. I can’t wait to make this carrot cake.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Susie, Allulose will work. I suggesting using granular for the cake and powdered for the frosting. It will be the same amount as written in the recipe. Enjoy!
Susie
Thank you I am going to make the carrot cake tomorrow
What is the difference between Erythritol and Allulose. I have your Allulose powder and crystallized and the Monk Fruit Allulose powder and crystallized.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Susie, Erythritol is a sugar alcohol and Allulose is a rare type of sugar. We can’t metabolize either, that’s what makes them great keto sweeteners! Where they differ is how they bake. Erythritol baked goods have a crisp texture, while allulose baked goods turn out golden brown and soft. I have an article that goes into more detail about keto sweeteners and their differences here: Sugar-Free Keto Sweeteners
Brittany
Could swerve be substituted for Erythritol, or is that Erythritol? Will the sweetness be the same?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Brittany, It is a blend that includes erythritol. You will need less of it for this recipe. Decrease the amount of your sweetener blend to 3/4 cup + 1 Tbs for this recipe. Enjoy!
Brittany
Thanks! But I am confused—I thought the original recipe calls for 3/4 cup sweetener in the cake batter, so what am I reducing? Thanks!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Brittany, My mistake!! Reduce the amount of sweetener to 1/2 cup + 1 Tbs. Sorry about that!
claudia d
Thank you!! Came out awesome <3
Yennenga
OMG! I made this cake today and it is 100% magical! I am a complete carrot cake addict and was sceptical about a sugar free version. I am blown away!
Also – recipes are often for US ingredients that are hard to find but I am in London and everything was easy to come by.
I can’t wait to share this with friends and family.
Viva la Sugarless Revolution!
Alyssia
Maya’s recipes are amazing!! So far my husband and I have loved ALL the ones I’ve tried.
I was having trouble deciding which to do next, and I’m gonna make this today because of your response.. lol
Sal
It was great. I overcooked the cake a bit so it broke when removed from silicon pan but no matter. We put layers of pressed down cake and cream cheese icing layers into a casserole dish and it made great very dense squares!
Mariel
This recipe is so delicious. Definitely 5 stars
Lara
Great recipe!! For some reason my batter was a little sticky (perhaps because I left out the pineapple extract and molasses) so I just added a little soy milk. My mum and my sister said it tasted like a normal carrot cake (I agree) – perfect for fulfilling a craving!
Vanessa
Hi, I have been making your recipes, so far, so good!
This carrot cake is fantastic even without the frosting, but with the cream cheese frosting is unbelievable good!
I have a question, can I freeze it?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Vanessa, Yes! Be sure to wrap it tightly and place it in a freezer-safe container. It will keep for 2 – 3 months.
Cam
Based on experience baking other almond flour and butter predominate recipes, after about 15 minutes of cooling after baking I put each cake on a plate upside down so that the butter doesn’t all run down to the bottom, and then put the cakes in the fridge to solidify the butter while it redistributes. If you leave it to cool without inverting the cakes you’ll end up with a pool of butter at the bottom of each cake. Much better to have an even distribution of butter.
Carol Erwin
This is a delicious carrot cake recipe! I also used your wonderful keto cream cheese frosting recipe with this cake. The only change I made was I stirred in some moist, chopped Medjool dates into the cake batter. My husband and I loved this cake and will definitely have it again.
Michelle Trabelsi
Love this recipe & so do all the family. What is nutritional value without frosting please?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Michelle, I am not sure. You can enter the recipe into an online recipe calculator to get nutrition counts without the frosting. Enjoy!
Jeff Turkot
I need to bake carrot cake cupcakes – what are adaptations; especially bake time in the oven?
Thanks,
Jeff
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Jeff, No changes needed. The bake time should be similar as well. I would start checking about 25 minutes in and then keep a close eye on them after that.
Resha
Hi, I was wondering if I could replace the almond flour with regular cake flour? If yes, would the quantity change? I basically have cut out added sugars but still eat some carbs and I do not have almond flour at hand at the moment
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Resha, I don’t know the answer to this question, but I assume it will not turn out the same. Wheat flour and almond flour have completely different properties.
Jeff Turkot
What are adaptations for baking cupcakes using this recipe?
Thanks
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Jeff, No changes needed. The bake time should be similar as well. I would start checking about 25 minutes in and then keep a close eye on them after that.
Pat Tyler
Husband’s favorite dessert, so I thought I’d give it a try. Gold medal!!! Nobel prize!!! James Beard, etc !!! He was prepared to be disappointed. Not! Better than store bought and it’s a keeper. Thank you. My only question is the icing ingredient powdered erythritol. Does it have the appearance and consistency of real powdered sugar? Couldn’t find in my stores, so used granulated monkfruit which I had on hand. Not bad but made slight grainy texture to the icing. Not sure what to look for because most powdered sugars are really overloaded with carbs.
Thanks again for the keeper.
Pat Tyler
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Pat, Yes, the powdered sweetener has the same texture and consistency of powdered sugar. Using granular sweetener will give you grainy frosting. Next time try using powdered and I know you’ll be thrilled with the result! You can find powdered allulose here: Best Powdered Allulose.
Pat
You can also run your granulated sweetener through a food processor or blender to make it finer. It does get airborne more when you open the lid so don’t breath deep.
Reagan
I loved this cake so much!
Andrée
Hello. Yesterday I made your carrot cake recipe, it is excellent. I also made the cream cheese frosting recipe and it was very good too. Thank you very much for all the beautiful recipes you share with us, I love all the recipes I have tried on your site. I also bought your book which I adoreeeeeee.
Sherry Binkelman
I forgot to add that I didn’t have any pineapple extract or molasses! I used about 1t maple extract instead.
Sherry Binkelman
Absolutely fantastic recipe! It was so moist and delicious! I also made your cream cheese frosting and it was also perfect! I’ve been keto for a year and a half and this is one of the best keto recipes I’ve made!
I added extra cinnamon and some pumpkin pie spice and would add a little more sweetener next time so that I could eat it w/out the frosting, but with the frosting it was sweet enough!
Phoebe
The recipe was great even without the frosting and the pecans ( I didn’t have them at home, lol ) the texture was great and it was moist! Will definitely make again !
Elizabeth Lijewski
Easy to follow and delicious recipe. Thanks for sharing.
Kate
Hi there, I would love to make this today but wanted to ask if once can sub the eggs with flax eggs to make it vegan?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Kate, I have not tested this recipe with flax egg, but I think the recipe should still work.
Eve Baillie
I don’t know what I did wrong but the cake was really dry and went in the bin. I was disappointed.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Eve, I’m sorry this didn’t turn out as expected. I’m happy to help you try to troubleshoot what went wrong if you would like to provide more detail. Also, there is a video in the recipe card if you would like a visual reference on what the batter and final should look like.
Brittany
Could you possibly have a video of a play by play – my cake stuck to the bottom of my pan
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Brittany, There is a video for this carrot cake in the recipe card. It is recommended that you use parchment paper in your cake pans. That will prevent sticking.
Terri K
I don’t have pineapple extract, so I was just going to use some pineapple juice or crushed pineapple- is that OK? if so how much- sorry if this question was already asked- I’m not able to see all the comments
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Terri, I suggest you omit the pineapple extract if you don’t have it. Many people love this recipe even without using the extract.
Siobhan Mccoulough
Hi
Can I make these into 12 cupcakes instead, do you think?
Thanks for your recipes I use them a lot and recommend to my clients.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Siobhan, Yes! This cake holds up well in cupcake form. Be sure to use liners so they don’t stick!
jenny gonzalez
hi i was just wondering how many cupcakes it makes and is the texture the same?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Jenny, This recipe will make approximately 12 cupcakes. The texture will be the same whether baked in a cupcake or cake round. I hope this helps!
Jim Alderfer
Hi Maya, I have made several recipes from your site and really enjoyed them all, THANKS! I started a Keto lifestyle several years ago and from a health and weight perspective it is the best thing I have ever done and your site has really helped make it possible. My wife started making a carrot cake recipe around Easter and it is the BEST carrot cake I have ever had! Unfortunately, I put the recipe through a nutrition calculator today and OMG! So I searched your website and found this recipe and can’t wait to try it. One question, the picture of the cake looks very flat compared to the one my wife makes, her finished cake is 4 inches high with each layer being almost 2 inches tall. Are the thin layers in the picture due to the almond flour?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Jim, Yes this cake will be about half the height of the version your wife made. It has a lot to do with using almond flour. Don’t let the size discourage you from making the recipe, it’s a delicious cake!
Mel
How do I ensure cupcakes won’t stick to pan?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Mel, The easiest way to do this is by using cupcake liners. It can be very difficult to remove cupcakes from their wells without using liners.
Laura
Hello—so excited to try out this recipe!! Carrot cake is my all time fav!! Any changes in bake time if it is prepared as a sheet cake? Thank you!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Laura, The bake time should be approximately the same, but keep an eye on it. Enjoy!
Shannon
This is the best carrot cake recipe, you absolutely cannot tell it’s low carb. Thank you so much for sharing it!
Daniela
Love this recipe. Making it for the third time this weekend. Using different filling though as I’m vegan 🙂
Isabel
I made this yesterday for Easter, absolutely delicious! It was just like the ‘real’ thing. Non-keto family members went in for seconds!!
amy rohl
I made this and it is DIVINE! My non-keto family had a look of astonishment when they tasted it, skeptical that it was actually low-carb. I didn’t have the pineapple extract or blackstrap molasses, but I did add a teaspoon of regular molasses, which I know is all sugar, but spread over the entire cake OK for my Keto journey. For the erythritol, I used a combination of three sweeteners. I also used the cream cheese frosting recipe – another DIVINE hit!
Thank you so much for this winning combination. And, for those of you wondering – definitely try this if you haven’t!
Brandi
Amazing, amazing, amazing.
My family loved them (I made 20 cupcakes with this recipe) and the frosting was amazing as well.
Thank you so much for this recipe:)
Mel
Hi Brandi. How long did they bake as cupcakes?
aubrey
You are easily my favorite recipe site. I have yet to make something that is not absolute perfection and this carrot cake is no exception. Thank you again!!
Joy
Hi. I would think that coconut flour would be a natural to use in this, so that it adds sweetness and flavour. Do you have a substitution for coconut flour, understanding you may have to add more eggs? If you have an alternate recipe with coconut flour, I would love to see that. Thank you
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Joy, I do not have a coconut flour substitution for this recipe. If you wanted to experiment with this idea on your own, please know that you will need less coconut flour than what is called for in the almond flour version. Coconut flour is very absorbent, so you will need quite a bit less. And yes, more eggs will be needed as well to help with structure and moisture. Best of luck!
Laura G
Hi there,
Next weekend is my husband’s birthday and I’m planning to surprise him with this awesome low carb carrot cake!!
Could you please let me know if I can freeze any leftovers ? Cause I was planning on cutting it into slices and freeze them, in that way we could enjoy it “in moderation”
Thanks for your wonderful recipes !!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Laura, I think it should work if you freeze individual slices. Be sure to wrap them well before going in the freezer!
Nonto
I made this cake today, came out so perfect! I didn’t have the molasses and pineapple extract, I added a bit of desiccated coconut and a bit less erythritol. Thanks for your page, its helping me a lot during this lockdown period. Going through the comments was very helpful as well.
Much thanks,
Nonto, South Africa.
ioana
This cake looks incredible and I can’t wait to make it but I am a bit confused about the amount of coconut oil or ghee I should add as a sub for butter. Kind regards
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Ioana, Please use the same amount as listed in the recipe (3/4 cup). You can measure these ingredients solid since they won’t soften at room temperature.
ioana
Thank you so much! I made the cake and it was beyond delicious. Used coconut oil and it was perfect. Everyone loved it. So happy, it makes me want to try all your recipes.
May
One of the most delicious recipes I ever tried, We are locked at home so I used stuff available using the mostly vegetarian ingredients, except eggs of course. Yesterday was my husband’s birthday, Luckily I had 5 medium carrots in the fridge which was exactly 2.5 cups, I replaced butter with organic coconut oil, and replaced sugar with 1/4 cup of honey, used 2 full eggs and 6 spoons of egg whites to reduce fat. Added 1/2 tsp of baking soda. And used the vanilla and 1 tsp of lemon zest. Also added a pinch of nutmeg.
For the topping, I mixed wiping cream, cream cheese, vanilla, and monk fruit sugar. After baking, I took the parchment paper and laid the cake on paper towels for 15 minutes to take the oil access to reduce fat since we are moving less during this difficult time.
Be safe, our prayers to save everyone.
Thy
I’m in the middle of making the cake, and I noticed that the butter Lakanto mixture started to curdle by the time i added pineapple extract and eggs. Has this happened to anyone? Is this normal? If not, is there anyway to salvage this?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Thy, This can happen if the eggs are very cold, they probably lowered the temperature of the butter and it solidified as a result. You can try eggs at room temperature next time – I updated the recipe card to reflect this. I usually get all my ingredients out first and my eggs were probably a bit warmer by the time I added them. This has happened to me before though with recipe testing, and if the butter separated from the eggs, I’ve scooped it up and heated gently to melt it. But if that doesn’t work, you might have to start over. Sorry this happened!
Also, just a small note, this recipe uses pure erythritol rather than Lakanto. You can use monk fruit sweetener, but it will be sweeter so would recommend using 70% of the erythritol amount listed. You might also like to try my Besti monk fruit sweetener, which uses a higher grade of monk fruit than other brands for an improved taste.
Sherry Binkelman
Mine curdled a bit, too, but I just carried on beating it a little more and although it was still a bit curdled looking, I just kept going as I knew it would not affect the texture (and indeed it didn’t!)
Roslyn
Mine started to curdle also…..but I kept going . The cake was still extremely delicious….didn’t seem to make a difference.
Val
Note to self: do not use pineapple juice instead of extract as it will curdle the ghee…
Jennifer
It’s delicious! Even without the molasses and pineapple extract. Just as good as the best carrot cake with regular flour. I didn’t make a double layer and I used less baking powder. Came out perfect for my taste. I prefer to refrigerate it.
Joanna
I baked them but they came oily:/
I see this problem with all recipes that include almond flour. When I use carbalose it’s fine, but instead with almond flour all cupcakes are wet/oily on the bottom :/ Any suggestions?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Joanna, The low carb flours are made from wheat and other starches, so they absorb the oils and moisture in baking. If you consistently have an issue with oily bottoms on your almond flour baked goods, then you can cut back slightly on the amount of fat used. For this carrot cake recipe, I would try cutting out 2-3 Tablespoons of butter to produce a less oily texture.
Eileen
It was -10 when I got up so it seemed the perfect day to try your carrot cake. I was concerned about the thickness so moved the batter from a 9×13 to a spring loaded pan. The batter “loosened” as it bakes and is cooling now, waiting for the cream cheese frosting! Can’t wait!!
Briana Roberts
Do you know the baking time and temperature for making these into cupcakes instead of a cake?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Briana, Bake at the same temperature, start checking for doneness around 20 minutes. Fully baked texture should be springy.
Christine
I make this recipe into cupcakes, since I can’t trust myself to cut a reasonable size slice of this deliciousness!! This way I have a little built in portion control 🙂
I Love this recipe, thanks for sharing it!
Nicole
Ugh, first time making this and I clearly did not understand the importance of using a springform pan or using parchment. I didn’t use either and the cake stuck despite greasing and then fell apart upon getting it out of the pan. The crumbs are all tasty and I’ve assembled it all into a cake layer like form. I’ll definitely give the recipe another shot, but just wanted to confirm that the batter is thick compared to a “normal” carrot cake, not liquidy at all?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Nicole, The batter is very thick for this cake recipe. I hope it comes out beautifully next time you try it!
Laquita
Thank you so much for the recipe. I tried it and the one thing that a couple people commented about was that the cake didn’t have a very “carroty” taste. I chopped, instead of grated, the carrots (due to time constraints). Would that make a difference? I’ve read other recipes containing apple – maybe that would bring out the carrot flavor? Your feedback would be much appreciated.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Laquita, Grated vs. chopped carrots will make a difference in the flavor of your cake. Smaller pieces (like grated) will give a stronger flavor profile. Apple can help bring out the flavors of carrot, but then it would no longer be a low carb cake.
Clo
I quartered his recipe and made one little cake for my hubby who had gastric sleeve surgery 3 months ago and needs to eat low carb, no sugar – it was his first real dessert in a long time and he loved it (but could only eat a few bites every few hours because of his tiny stomach) – he said it tasted like REAL carrot cake (his favorite). I had a bite and yep it sure did. I did not use the optional molasses or extract – and I used ‘I cant believe it’s not butter’ (don’t be mad) and Splenda for the frosting i used I cant believe it’s not butter and light cream cheese and Splenda. so…..I didn’t really use your recipes but you certainly gave me all the ideas & direction I needed to be successful with almond flour and I thank you very much. I’m actually going to make a full size cake for Christmas, it’s good enough for regular non-dieters.
Samara
This was amazing! So often these types of recipes fall short for me and my family, but this was so good I’m going to make this for our Xmas lunch instead of fruit cake.
Ummie
AMAZING CAKE!
so delicious and moist and just a perfect cake! My family enjoyed it!
I remember reading a comment saying the cake turned out dry, I think it might be because of using too much almond flour, since it can easily over packed when measuring with a cup (its dense and almost moist like). So you might have ended up using too much almond flour. I spooned it on to the measuring cup and used a knife to level it, to avoid over packing the cup. The cake turned out better tben I had expected! Thank you for sharing this recipe, it made my husbands birthday so much more special:))
Talia Maloof
What are the exact measurements for this recipe???
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Talia, The measurements are found in the recipe card. You may need to turn off your reader mode to find them.
Jennifer Jones
This cake is amazing!
Carol
The BEST carrot cake ever!!!!Everyone loves it…even if they are not on a keto diet !
Brittany
I am not on a low carb/keto/sugar-free diet at all. I made this cake because I have a friend who is low carb, her birthday was recently and her favourite cake is Carrot Cake. I’ve had low carb baking before and while my friends who haven’t eaten real sugar in months rave about how good these desserts are I always find them bland and honestly disgusting. I’ve played it off as being too full from dinner to not hurt anyone’s feelings but I hate sugar-free food. I’ll diet no problem, but the carb-free life isn’t for me.
That being said; This cake was freaking amazing. I’m not sure if it had to do with the type of fake sugar I used or what but I followed the recipe exactly for the cake and the buttercream(Doubled). I could only taste the chemical taste of the fake sugars a tiny bit in the icing. This is a big deal because normally that is all I can taste. It was so good. My friends were almost in tears because they said it was the best low carb dessert they’ve had in a long time. My husband who is a red-seal chef helped me make it so maybe that had something to do with it and he also wasn’t comfortable leaving it in for the 30-35 minutes it stated. I think we only had it in the oven for about 25 minutes give or take a couple of minutes. I’ve sent it to everyone who had the cake that night and they were all super jazzed. Well done, this recipe is a definite win.
Trish
Hi Maya,
I made so many of your recipes and so grateful that I found your site. I have been baking keto for years before it was popular but there were not many good recipes but yours are absolutely the best!!!.
Now my question is when I make your carrot cake can I use swerve brown sugar instead of the powdered.? Also I want to add some spices. Like cinnamon, nutmeg and cardamom. I don’t know how much to use. I made your cream cheese icing and added cinnamon and it was spectacular. Now I need a carrot cake to go with it. My neighbors went crazy over it. Yesterday I made your strawberry cake into muffins with the same icing added strawberries to it. Yummy.
Thanks so much
Trish
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Trish, I am so thrilled you are enjoying the recipes! Yes, you can use brown sweetener in place of the erythritol in the cake, but I wouldn’t use brown sweetener in place for the powdered sweetener in the frosting. The cake already includes cinnamon, if you wanted to add additional spices, I suggest 1/4 tsp of cardamom and 1/8 tsp of nutmeg. I hope you love it!
Lynn
It seemed to come out dry. Is there something that could be substituted to make it a bit more moist?
Wholesome Yum A
Hi Lynn, it might be overbaked if it’s dry, so try reducing the baking time. Other than that you can add more butter if you’d like but I didn’t find that necessary.
Kurtis
I made these into muffins. It made 18 regular size and I only needed 1 batch of the icing noted in the recipe. These are quite good, moist and certainly satisfies the old “sweet” tooth. I’ll definitely be making again. Love all the recipes I’ve found, thank you for sharing. It has made starting Keto so much more enjoyable.
Megan Malin
So, I made this recipe for the first time today and am very pleased with the results. I have tried many other recipes from other sources and was never happy with any of the resulting products. This was everything I was looking for…tender, flavorful, delicate…..sooo good!
Thank you for sharing this lovely recipe!!
Gigi
I made this cake today, and whilst the flavours are good it is extremely dry! I followed the recipe exactly, and have triple checked everything. I don’t understand how there are so many comments about how moist it is. My cake batter was pretty solid before baking which I was worried about at the time, but I trusted the recipe and thought it might work out. Well I should have followed my instincts! I might make this again but when I do, I’m going to reduce the amount of almond flour.
PAPAW GIG
Saturday I am celebrating my 70 years of LIFE along with my Christian brother, business partner and best friend who is celebrating his 77th annual date of his DELIVERY.
Another of our business associates is baking THIS cake as a KETO FRIENDLY carrot cake and we are introducing it to many of our families and friends.
I’ll let you know how it turns out.
Julie
Hi, I am all set to make this but I cannot see how many eggs to use??
The reviews look so good I have to try this cake!
Wholesome Yum A
Hi Julie, it’s four large eggs!
Shakira
Hiya
Are you able to make this in a loaf instead?
Thanks
Shakira
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Shakira, It will take longer to bake through, but the recipe will work fine in a loaf pan.
Ashley
Just thought I’d share a funny story – one that shows how darn good this recipe is.
My family and I travel full-time in a camper. My oven broke a while back, so I use our pressure cooker for everything. Also, I gave ALL my baking supplies other than a few things away before we moved in because I thought we’d lack the space.
So, today is my husband’s birthday, and carrot cake is his absolute favorite, but he didn’t want one unless I could eat it with him. So I decided to make THIS recipe in a pressure cooker and see how it turned out.
Bought all the ingredients, using monk fruit sweeter instead of erythritol in both the icing and the cake, and lemon extract instead of pineapple (because I couldn’t find it). No molasses because I couldn’t find that, either. We are in the actual middle of nowhere, so grocery supplies are limited. Still shocked that they have monk fruit but no molasses.
Then I get home last night, and I cannot find my small cake pans that will fit in the pressure cooker. Yay.
Finally, hubs found an old metal dog bowl that my dog won’t use because he’s terrified of the steel color. LOL.
So anyway, I baked the cake in a dog bowl in my pressure cooker, two layers, added cinnamon to the icing because I ran out of vanilla. Oh yeah, my son poured water in the butter while it was sitting to room temp. So probably a tbsp of water that shouldn’t be in there mixed in. hahahaha.
It still turned out delicious, and it has little paw prints embedded on the bottom.
It’s more moist, less brown, and probably more dense than if cooked in an oven, but it does work, and it is wonderful.
Thanks for this great recipe that can basically withstand a disaster.
Wholesome Yum
I LOVE this story, Ashley! Thank you for sharing! 🙂
Ashley
Thanks for reading it! Lol!
My husband just finished the rest of the cake for dinner. . He said this is the best he’s ever had, and he’d choose this over “a regular normal cake” any day.
Thanks again for an awesome addition to our treats. 🙂
Georgina Mojardin
This is the best Keto Carrot cake recipe ever. I make this for my family and friends and co workers. And they love it even though they are not on the Keto diet. I have some non Keto people get seconds!!!!!
Mariana Mariles Alvarez
I love carrot cake and haven’t had it since I went on a low carb diet, this is the best recipe ever, everyone in my family loved it. My to go carrot cake from now on without the guilt, thank you!
Angela
I tried to make this today. Sadly, I did not put parchment paper on the bottom of the pans. Now the cakes won’t come out and they have crumbled. It is impossible to assemble the cake. I am upset with myself. I did not realize parchment paper is so important. I also do not quite understand how to bake with almond flour because it does not hold up well in cakes or cookies. Live and learn.
Szilard Molnar
Thank you very much for this recipe! I baked it for my wife’s birthday because she loves carrot cake, but I wanted to find a sugar free option. It worked perfectly, we both loved it!!!
Hannah
Made this twice and in love.
Katey
Yum! I made this for my husband for his bday and it was a huge hit!! I ended up using lactose free butter and cream cheese. I also used local honey instead of other sweetners which i know isnt keto.. but tasted amazing! So moist and so delicious.
Byenia
Made this recipe a couple days back and loved it! Boyfriend loved it too, and planning to share it with my best guyfriend as well. Reduced the recipe by half since we wanted a small cake, and added the xanthan gum & baking soda as recommended by other commenters. Skipped the optional molasses and pineapple extract. Used half pecans and half walnuts for the nuts. Decided to try out a cream cheese/greek yogurt frosting to accompany this, but next time I’ll likely try your cream cheese frosting recipe instead. Thanks so much! This was very tasty and has a great texture! 🙂
Jessica
Can you freeze this cake? I’m thinking in individual pieces to have on hand.
Wholesome Yum
Hi Jessica, you should be able to do that. Let me know how it goes!
Pam Cameron
The reviews are right, AMAZING! I’m not a “baker” but had to try this as my husband is type 2 diabetic and we occasionally need a good treat. this is so good, and not difficult, which is important for me. Didn’t have molasses or the pineapple extract (getting some) but enjoyed it without. I took an earlier suggestion of adding 1/2 teaspoon xanthan gum and 1/2 teaspoon baking soda. The cake was moist, not too crumbly and with the frosting, perfect sweetness. I didn’t have erythritol so did some calculations and used Fructevia (about 4 tablespoons) which seems fine. Thank you so much. This is a big hit and I’ll be sharing with my friends who don’t beleive you can have yummy baked goods without sugar. Love your recipes.
Lisa
Can this be made in Cupcakes?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Lisa, Yes, you can do that. The oven time will probably be around 25 minutes.
Estelle
I’d been hungry for carrot cake for a long time. I happened to be the recipient of some fresh home grown carrots and decided to make this cake. It is delicious and was satiated my hunger for carrot cake. I made it in a 9X13 pan and it was perfect with the double recipe of the cream cheese frosting! Thank you Maya for the great recipe!
Marcy Smith
This carrot cake was amazing! I just made it for myself for Easter, the rest of my family is full carbohydrate and sugar. I make stuff for them but leave myself out most of the time. I made my dessert a priority this holiday and I am so thrilled I did!
I substituted walnuts for the pecans as that is my family’s tradition with carrot cake. I didn’t have the pineapple extract, and I made the dairy-free option. I used Switch from Thrive Market as the sweetener for the cake, that was all I had. I found a dairy-free cream cheese frosting recipe and used that recipe. The frosting was not just like the dairy version, but I felt the cake was just like a flour and dairy version. Perhaps it didn’t rise as high as a flour cake, but the taste and texture was bang on! Thank you so very much for this recipe! You really made my holiday great. I am going to have another slice now!
Brenna
Made this for Easter (2019) and everyone loved it! My Husband even to seconds! Even with the confectioners swerve I still found the frosting a bit grainy, but my dad thought it was great. (and that is coming from a man who can complain about anything.)
Kathy Packard
Does the carb count include the molasses?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Kathy, Yes, it does.
Gloria
Omygod! I had 22 guests, my keto carrot cake and a chocolate cake. I did double up on the cream cheese for this recipe, and a bit more butter for the icing. It was so incredibly popular. Everyone truly loved it.
Marylyn
Can I use drained crushed pineapple to this cake? I love carrot cake with pineapple.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Marylyn, You’d need to make other changes to add pineapple, it would make the cake too wet. I have pineapple extract in the recipe for this very reason and recommend using that.
Jennifer
I made this cake this afternoon and it is positively yummy! Can’t believe that it is low carb! My husband raved about it with every bite! I hope you have more yummy recipes for low carb dieting! Thanks so much for this one! I will be making it again and again!
Mabel
OMG, this dessert was absolutely outrageous! My guest couldn’t believe that it was made with almond flour and swerve. Only adjustment made omitted pineapple extract and blackstrap molasses and added ½ teaspoon of xanthan gum and ½ teaspoon of baking soda. Texture was moist, not dense, did not taste like almond flour, did not crumble and was extremely flavorful. BTW, this is my first review ever, so thank you so much for all your contributions and excellent details. This recipe is a keeper!
Samantha Rowland
As a baker I’m experimenting more with keto creations as I have recently gone semi-keto (mostly low carb).
I like the simplicity of ingredients and it was easy to make. I used Stevia in the Raw with a ratio of 1:1 , so 3/4c same as the Erythritol. I found that the texture and flavors were lovely, but it wasn’t very sweet, at all. I think I’m going to up the sugar for next time but overall great recipe.
Emily
I baked this last week and it was the first cake I have baked in my life! Being a T1 diabetic cakes were off limits.. Thank you for this recipe it worked perfectly now I’m going to try other low carb baking!
Chris
I’m a little confused on the pecans. When I measure 1Cup of crushed pecans, I then put it on my scale and I’m only getting about 130g as the measurement. This is no where near the 340g you have stated. Should I stick to my measuring cup or go all the way up to 340?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Chris, Sorry about that. The recipe calls for 148.5g pecans, which is correct, but the weights in the instructions were off. I updated them.
Lisa
Fingers crossed. Ordered all the ingredients. Will make this for my husband’s birthday April 6th as carrot cake is his favorite.
Marcia
Dear Maya: I made this as a birthday cake for my sweetie, who was diagnoses with Type II Diabetes a few months ago. Everyone at the table loved it, and my (30-something) son was sneaking bites of mine off my plate when I wasn’t looking. This one’s definitely a keeper! First, I made a 1/2 recipe as I always do, since 6 slices, with no leftovers, is just right for us. As for the recipe, I used powdered monk fruit instead of erythritol, which was fine. And I didn’t use molasses or pineapple extract, because I didn’t have either of those on hand, but will add them next time. The cream cheese frosting? Well… I forgot to get cream cheese. I tried to use creme fraich instead, but that was *not* a success. Wound up using some additional creme fraich as frosting, and will remember to get cream cheese before the next time. Thank you so much for a tasty dessert that is just as good as a traditional recipe. Question: Would adding raisins or pineapple be okay for a diabetic-friendly recipe, or would those up the sugar too much? TIA for your advice.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Marcia, I’m so glad you and your family liked the cake! Raisins or pineapple would not be low carb or keto, but in small amounts I’m sure some diabetics might be able to have them as part of a low carb cake. Pineapple would also make the cake more wet so would not recommend adding that, but from a recipe standpoint raisins are fine.
Marcia
Lisa – I had to laugh, as I just made this for *my* partner’s April 6th birthday. It was a hit here at our house. I hope it turned out okay for you as well.
Darlene
Hi Maya,
I am so thankful I found your website through Pinterest. Have made your donuts and blueberry muffins recipes multiple times. You’re so thorough in your decsciptions and research. My question today is about the carrot cake. It came out so delicious but crumbed when taking it out of the pan. Would using parchment paper help or do you have another suggestion? Or is it the timing after I take it out of the oven to cool? This is my first cake so, appreciate any suggestions you can provide.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you so much, Darlene! Yes, definitely use parchment paper to line the bottom of the pan, and grease the sides. You could also use a springform pan but that’s not required as long as you use parchment paper. It could be the timing as well – it has to cool completely before removing it from the pan. I’m glad it was still delicious!
Doreen
Maya, this is absolutely delicious!! Thank you. I thought I was going to have to be carrot cake free for life…you’re a life saver. It’s really the only (apart from lemon drizzle cake) I’ve actually had a hankering for since going keto a few years ago. Bless you!
Heather
WOW!!! I can’t believe how amazing this cake tasted and turned out!! I think it’s even better than non-keto carrot cakes I’ve had… I couldn’t get enough! I didn’t have the molasses or pineapple extract, but still turned out perfectly. Thanks so much for this recipe 😀
Vee
I made these into muffins. I’m terrible at baking but I wanted to try this anyway since my hubs is on low carb and loves carrot cake. He asked for no sugar and they came out pretty good without it!! It’s a great idea to grab and go too if you do muffins.
Luther McNabb
Can you freeze this cake? There are only 2 of us. Thanks. My husband loved his birthday cake!!!!!!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Luther, Yes, you can freeze it. So nice of you to make this homemade birthday cake for him!
Denise
How big are they and do they rise or are they kinda flat? I’m going to try and make cupcakes for a birthday with this.
Matt
Hi! The recipe looked great and the cake tasted great, too. However, one of my pans crumbled when I tried to invert after cooling. Would you know why? Also I had to spoon the batter into the pan, wasn’t that liquidy to pour itself on to the pan. Pretty sure I followed the recipe to a t. Any insight would be helpful! Thanks!
Conni Taz
This was absolutely delicious. Best keto dessert I’ve had. I was wondering if you ever substituted the carrots for zucchini to lower the net carbs? Thanks so much for posting this recipe it is incredible
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Conni! I haven’t tried it with zucchini. It might work, but you’d have to sprinkle it with salt, let it drain over the sink, and then squeeze out the extra moisture before using it in the cake. Zucchini has higher water content than carrots.
Heather
Aahhh! I was wondering the same thing! I actually froze some from the summer, salted and drained already. I’m going to thaw and drain them and try it….stay tuned
Michelle
Hi Maya, I love your recipe! I made these into cupcakes and they were sooooooooooooo delicious and well received by everyone who tried them!
Angela Madden
So darn good! I LOVE this recipe!! Really craving carrot cake and made this recipe with ingredients as is, except I made a 9×13 pan size. Thank you so very much it’s DELICIOUS
Jeanna
How long did you bake it in the 13 x 9 pan; and did you need to double the frosting (as called for in the 2-layer version)?
Thank you!
Celeste Glass
Hi there, looks like the best recipe I’ve seen so far. One question, can I replace the erythritol with xylitol? I just can’t handle the taste of erythritol.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Celeste, Yes, you can do that! You’d need a little less – check the low carb sweetener conversion calculator here.
Simone Hrycenko
Outstanding carrot cake – as good as any I have had. Thank-you for taking the time to craft and share this recipe. Mine turned out moist, not crumbly. Almost seemed better the second day after it had time to rest and meld. I added some orange zest (1tsp) to the icing and it went over well. I used the “Golden” monkfruit sweetner by Lakanto in the cake, and their powdered monkfruit sweetner in the icing. Flour was the extra fine almond flour offered at Costco. We have been eating keto for nearly two years; this recipe definitely elevated my dessert game.
Tara
Hi Maya, I’m about to bake this recipe and was wondering if you have tried a version replacing eggs. I know of “flaxseed eggs”, but have recently used this version and the cake was a disaster (not your recipe). Thank you
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Tara, Sorry, I haven’t tried it without eggs. The substitutes I’ve seen people use are flax eggs or chia eggs, but can’t say how it would turn out for this recipe.
Tara
Thanks so much for responding, I’ll give it a go and see how it turns out in the next few days.
Jodie Palasantza
I only have one cake tin. Would this recipe work as one big cake rather than two layers if I increase the cooking time?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Jodie, You could do that, but you may need to cover the top part-way through to avoid burning the top before the center is done baking. You could also try making it in a 9×13 pan, cut that in half, and then stack the two halves to make a square cake. Of course baking time would still need adjustment with any pan different from the size the recipe is written for.
Mj Rad
This recipe is divine. I made this for my husband’s birthday and it tasted like a normal carrot cake. Everyone was happy and cannot believe it was a keto cake. No modification with the recipe but I may try to put xantham gum for the cake not to be crumbly. Again, thanks for the recipe.
Magda
I made this carrot cake for Christmas. It is awesome. I doubled the recipe to make one big cake, substituted pecans with chopped walnuts, used ground almonds and omitted molases and pineapple exctract but added instead gingerbread spices. Purely because I used what I already had in my pantry. Usually, the pictures in recipes are far better then the final product when you do it at home. Not this time! I think mine was even more impressive! Keto or no keto this carrot cake it’s just perfect. Dense, moist, sweet, full of flavour. Thank you so much for sharing this recipe.
Karen
I have looked at the “sugar” replacement charts. They don’t help me. I cannot buy erythritol where I am but stevia is everywhere and I HATE the aftertaste. I need a sweetener that doesn’t spike insulin – so no coconut sugar. Today I found monk fruit powder. How do I replace the erythritol in your recipe with monk fruit? Thank you for this site.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Karen, The amount of monk fruit depends on the brand; some are pure whereas others contain other ingredients. You don’t need to use the chart, just use the conversion calculator here.
Karen
Thank you. As noted in the email reply, the conversion chart does not list powdered stevia. It works better if the TYPE of sweetener was listed, alphabetically, then by product. Thus: erythritol – , Monk fruit – Lakanto, Stevia -liquid stevia – dry, Xylitol – etc.
Jared
Awesome recipe, thanks for sharing. My girlfriend is okay with a little crushed pineapple, so how much pineapple should we add in place of subtracting some erythritol??
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Jared, I haven’t tried it so can’t say for sure. Most likely you’d need to make multiple adjustments to the recipe, because replacing some erythritol with pineapple would make the batter more runny, and the cake might not set.
April Abbott
I am very impressed. Husband is keto and carrot cake is his favorite dessert. I’m sugar-free and low carb also so this recipe pleased us both. I omitted the molasses. Added a tsp of xantham gum. Also, I added a 1/4 cup of no sugar added applesauce for sweetness and moisture and 1/4 tsp of nutmeg. (something I always did to my regular carrot cake in the past). Interestingly, initially, I was not impressed. It didn’t quite taste sweet enough and was kind of so-so when we tried to dig in the first night. Husband loved it immediately though. But today, after letting it sit overnight, the flavor really comes through and it is very moist and flavorful. So sitting for a while really helped. I do like my carrot cake a little on the spicy side, so next time I will probably add a little more cinnamon. Overall a great recipe that I will share with my keto and paleo friends. Thanks so much!
Jeannie
My husband is diabetic and I am always on the hunt for desserts for family gatherings. This one was Awesome! I often stay away from almond flour (he doesn’t like almonds) but thought the carrots might counter balance it. I did make a few modifications because of that too. I substituted a cup of almond flour for 1/4 c. Coconut flour, 2 additional eggs, 1/4 c. Butter, and 1/4 c. sweetner. (They are such different flours). …the modification was successful and helped lighten the almond taste I try to avoid.
He often cringed when I try a new recipe because we have had some bad ones, but he loves this one. Moist, good flavor. Nice to provide a dessert that everyone can enjoy that he doesn’t feel left out.
LeeAnn Anderson
Looks amazing. If making as cupcakes, would you modify anything other than maybe the cooking time?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, LeeAnn! You should be able to keep everything the same if making cupcakes, just reduce the baking time. I suppose the amount of frosting needed might be different, too.
Beth
oooh nice one. I’m not a very good baker so it always feels miraculous when something turns out nicely- especially something I can actually eat on my weird diet! It was gorgeously moist and dense. The cakes were pretty thin by the time i split the batter (though that was fine for what I needed). Next time I might experiment with tin sizes.
I layered it with very thin slices of orange and coconut yogurt <3 this cake LOVED the orange!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked the cake, Beth! Thanks for stopping by!
Joanie McCann
I followed the recipe but didn’t have almond flour. I used coconut flour. It came out like cookie dough instead of batter! How could I thin it out?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Joanie, Sorry, coconut flour doesn’t work well in this recipe at all. As you found, it’s very drying and requires a totally different recipe, but even then you get a more dense result. You could try adding a bunch of eggs and milk, but that would throw off the sweetener balance. You really need a coconut flour recipe if you’d like to use that. Hope you’ll try this again with almond flour.
Carole
Maya, I love this carrot cake recipe. The first time I made it, I cut the recipe in half because it is just me and I don’t need a big cake. I made the cream cheese frosting and it was delicious. Since then, I discovered I need to stay away from dairy. I decided to make this cake again only this time I invented a glaze to put on it. I use both the molasses and pineapple extract (which I could find anywhere and I ordered it online). For the glaze for half the cake: 1/4C coconut oil, 1/4C coconut butter, 1T powdered erythritol and 1/8 tsp pineapple extract. Melt the coconut oil and butter in a pan, add erythritol, take off heat, add pineapple extract and pour onto cake and spread around. Top with unsweetened shredded coconut. SO DELICIOUS!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am happy you liked the cake, Carole! Thanks for stopping by!
Mike
Hello, My wife is on this keto kick and usually, I would make the southern fatty carrot cake but not this year. 🙂 I did omit the 1 tbsp blackstrap molasses and pineapple extract. The molasses creates a flavor I don’t care for in carrot cake and I used 1/4 a real pineapple that was cut into 1/4 inch sheets and slightly dehydrated in a convection oven @ 400 for 10 minutes. I let them cool and cubed to 1/4 inch, roughly 1 cup. I also cut the cinnamon down to 1 tsp, cut the carrots down to 2 cups and used multi-colored heirloom ones. The interior pecans were cut down to 1/2 cup to make room for the pineapple and 1 cup coconut rough fresh flakes.
The cakes took me 38 minutes to pull a toothpick clean but never got a springy top like you would on bread… I would think if you cooked to get that result it would be well overcooked. Oh yes, I also replaced the vanilla extract with vanilla paste in the cake and frosting. In the frosting, I did not add any cream as the texture felt right for a cream cheese butter frosting but I did add 1 additional cup of the powdered erythritol as the sweet taste was not there for me. I let you know how this goes over in a few…
Thanks for the inspiration.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you for sharing, Mike! I can’t say how it would turn out with all those modifications, but please let us know how it went.
Carole
I want to make this cake – well half of this cake. It’s just me here so I think I will cut the cake in recipe in half. I live in the mountains of N. California and could not find pineapple extract anywhere. I found it on Amazon, it was spendy but I thought I could use it for other things and have ordered it. Can’t wait to try this cake – it will be for my 66th birthday cake next week!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Happy birthday, Carole! I hope you like it!
Kemi
Where to get almond flour?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Kemi, You can get almond flour here. Many grocery stores also carry it in the baking area.
Sil
OMG. I have been looking forward to making this for about a month. I made it yesterday and I’m about to cut all portions and hide them so I don’t eat the whole thing at a time!! I used more carrots than the recipe calls for (I put baby carrots in food processor and used about 3 cups of processed carrots) and also used whole walnuts. Removed all the optionals and used stevia instead (about a 1/4 cup of powdered stevia). I am so happy this turned out so good!! My new go-to keto dessert!!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked the cake, Sil! Please come back soon!
Kristen
Hi,
I am going to bake this tomorrow. I bought Pyure all purpose. I checked your sweetener conversion chart but still aren’t sure how much of the Pyure to use. I was going to put 1/2 cup.
Also can you bake in a 13 by 9 inch pan, the whole amount of batter?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Kristen, There’s a sweetener conversion calculator here that you can use. Yes, you should be able to use a 9 x 13 pan.
Reneel
Maya!!! This cake is sooooo good! I made a couple changes based on the comments left by other folks. I added a 1/4 tsp xanthum gum, 1/2 tsp more of baking powder and about 1 tbsp of olive oil to the carrots. I also did not shred the carrots, instead they were food processed into bits. The cake was so moist and there was actually a good rise to the cake. Don’t get me wrong, it was still dense, but moist and delicious!! I am so glad you posted this recipe! Thank you so much! BTW, the icing was fantastic too…I dropped a little of it into my coffee and well, it may be my new sweetener for my morning coffee 🙂
Maya | Wholesome Yum
What a great idea to sweeten your coffee, Renee!:) Thanks for stopping by!
Skitch
The cake part came out dry. My carrots were manually shredded (by me). Is there something else that could be added to help make the cake more moist? The icing was awesome though! Thank you. This is a good recipe otherwise.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Skitch, It might be overbaked if it’s dry, so try reducing the baking time. Other than that you can add more butter if you’d like but I didn’t find that necessary.
vicky
Amazing!!!! I changed butter for coconut oil. And It was super good!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy to hear that, Vicky! Thanks for stopping by!
Rita
Hi just tasted,the carrot cake made into muffins. I only have 3 words wow wow wow. So yum moist flavorful. Don’t need any frosting perfect as is. Thank you!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am glad you liked it, Rita! Thanks for stopping by!
Robyn
Can these be made into muffins?
And how long would you bake them?
Looks delicious!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Robyn, Yes, you can make muffins with this batter. I haven’t tried to say the time but other readers say they have. I’d start checking after 22 min and every few min after until a toothpick comes out clean.
Rita
Hi, Can’t wait to try the cake but says cream sugar and butter or coconut oil. I never used coconut oil without making it liquid in a pan melting it. Will it work to take it as is in jar and I mix with sugar? Or should I melt it first? Thanks, can’t wait to hear and make carrot cake.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Rita, Don’t melt it first. Use a hand mixer to beat the butter or coconut oil (in soft solid form) with the sweetener.
Bayan
I made this yesterday it was so good!
Of course I will make it again.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked it, Bayan! Thanks for stopping by!
Helen
This is just perfect. Made today and sat eating it with my husband. Wish I could post you a picture. I put half pecans and half walnuts. Very moist and incredibly tasty. Thank you for your lovely recipe.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked the cake, Helen! Thanks for stopping by!
Sarah
Hi, I’ve always had carrot cake for my bday, and I’m making myself this one this year. my only question is all the carrot cakes I’ve every had have shredded coconut in them. Do you think I could sub out part of the carrot for unsweetened coconut flakes?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Sarah, The carrot provides moisture and coconut absorbs moisture, so if you make that swap you’d need to add liquid. I can’t say how much without trying it. I think it’s probably safer to keep the carrot the same and add shredded coconut in addition. Then if you add just a bit you might be able to keep everything else the same, or if it’s more, like 1/2 cup, you probably need to add more moisture still. Let me know how it goes if you try modifying!
Sarah
I subbed out part of the carrot for the coconut and it turned out amazing. I think it was more like a muffin than cupcake but I was not at all disappointed. The whole family loved them!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you for sharing! I’m glad that worked!
Sarah
I also left out the nuts since none of my family much cares for them, so I think that helped.
Stacey
This was my first attempt at any keto baking. My husband has been struggling with giving up the sweets and it was his birthday. I was surprised how easy it was. He was very happy with it and determined now that he could do this. Looking forward to trying many more recipes
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Stacey! Happy birthday to your husband!
Jen
We really enjoyed the carrot cake. I didn’t have the pineapple extract, so I replaced it with orange extract, and it was terrific. I used the cream cheese frosting as well… but I didn’t put as much sweetener in it and added more vanilla.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you so much, Jen! Great idea with the orange extract, too.
Randall
Thanks for posting this carrot cake recipe. I’m a baker but new to Keto baking. My cake came out just a little on the dry side and didn’t seem to rise at all. Do you think it would have worked out better adding another tsp of baking powder, some xanthan gum and a little liquid? I’d really appreciate your thoughts and advice.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Randall, Thank you for the feedback. Did you by chance use pre-shredded carrots? Those are more dry. Otherwise it could just be variation in how “wet” your carrots were in general. Aside from that, keto flours don’t rise as much as regular wheat flour, so that’s pretty expected. You can try a bit more baking powder, but too much has the opposite effect and causes falling. Xanthan gum can definitely be used to improve the texture – try 1/2 tsp.
Randall
Thank you so much for your advice. I did shred my carrots myself but they may not have lent enough moisture. I am going try adding the xanthan gum but leave the baking powder as is (there’s no use in risking over doing it for just a little more height). I am determined to figure out the art of Keto baking.
Vicki
Oh my, this was just sooooo delicious, I even had the black strap molasses and sugar free pineapple syrup which I did include. Made the cake recipe exactly as instructed and it came out perfectly. The only modification was to the frosting where I used less sweetener and cream cheese but more butter but I am sure it is lovely as written.. Will be trying more of your recipes from now on. Thank you
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you so much, Vicki! I’m so glad you liked it.
Sonya
I would love to make this for my hubby’s birthday but would prefer to use raw agave syrup for the sweetener instead of the sweeteners. Would this make the batter too runny?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Sonya, I haven’t tried that but it probably would be too runny. If you prefer to use a natural sugar sweetener over erythritol, you can try coconut sugar instead.
Cyndi Rose
I made this today for my husband’s birthday. It was seriously good. I’ve always made my carrot cakes from scratch but never low carb before. I used Swerve and if I hadn’t been the one to make it, I would have never guessed it was low carb, sugar-free and not regular flour. My 11-year old daughter loved it. Thanks so much! This will be my go-to cake recipe for future gatherings.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy to hear the whole family enjoyed the cake, Cyndi! Happy birthday to your husband!
Sarah
This sounds amazing! Going to try making it now but is it ok to use Truvia instead of erythrytol? Truvia is basically 95% erythritol and grainy like sugar… just wasn’t sure if it would be too sweet. Anyone tried this?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Sarah! Yes, you can use Truvia, you’d just need a little less. Check my conversion chart here.
sarah
thank you! i used truvia, left out the pineapple and molasses, and subbed walnuts for the pecans and it was a HIT! my mom loved them even without the frosting lol they were moist, delicious, and healthy 🙂 i used leftover carrot pulp from my juicer and you couldnt even see any carrot pieces. this is def a recipe i’ll use again and again. thank you, maya!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy to hear that, Sarah!
Caroline
This cake is delicious. I have been putting in less sweetner and more cinamon since the first time i made it. Ive made 3 in the past fortnight! Have also left out the blackstrap and the pineapple extract. Its amazing! Thanks for the recipe!!xx
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked it, Caroline!
Marla
I made this cale last night @8:00pm after googling keto carrot cake and had a serious craving for it and as it tirns out it was a smash! Hubby loves it and i cant believe how good and sweet it is. I didnt have heavy cream for the frostso i used almond milk instead and it was delicious also didnt have the pineapple or molasses so i can imagine how good these would make it. Anyway thanks for the wonderful recipe!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked it, Marla!
Nanette
Can I replace carrot with zucchini?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Nanette, I haven’t tried but you probably can. Squeeze it to drain well first because it has more moisture than carrots.
Christine Mayfield
This cake is amazing!!! It is moist and flavorful. It is so hard to eat just one piece. Next time I’ll make sure I have parchment paper :D. Thank you for sharing this recipe. It helps me to #KetoOn
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you enjoyed the cake, Christine! Have a great day!
Jacky
Can I replace the blackstrap molasses with Sukrin Gold?? Thanks I really want to try this cake!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Jacky, You can, though the result will be a little different. Blackstrap molasses is very concentrated in flavor, whereas Sukrin Gold is mostly a sweetener with a more mild flavor. I think it would be good either way!
Karyn M.
This is AMAZING!! If there was an option to give it 100 stars I would! I was expecting the usual dry, bland sugar-free cake but this is so good! It’s very, very tasty and moist- plus the frosting is out of this world!
Unfortunately, I wasn’t able to eat just one slice. LOL
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you so much, Karyn! That means a lot and I’m glad you liked it so much. Sometimes two slices is necessary 😉
Mari
Can I use a 13×9 pan for this recipe?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Mari, Yes, you can! I think you can just put all the batter in a single layer instead of two 9-inch pans. The baking time may be a little longer. When done, just cut it in half and you can stack the two pieces just like you would round cakes.
Cheryl
I am wondering if I can do this in a 9×13 or cupcakes? Would there be any adjustment?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Cheryl, Yes, definitely! The only adjustments would be baking time. The muffins would definitely take less time, and the 9×13 pan would probably take more time. You can use a toothpick to check for doneness.
Anni Mclaughlin
I just finished mixing the batter for this yummy sounding cake for our “family night” tonight. I followed the recipe (except substituting walnuts for the pecans) the batter was very thick, more like cookie dough than a typical cake. It that the way yours was too? My family will be thrilled with it no matter what…just checking in.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Anni, The batter is fairly thick, but not quite as thick as cookie dough. Did you shred the carrots yourself? They provide some of the moisture in the batter, so if using pre-shredded carrots, it may be too dry. I hope the cake still turned out delicious for you!
Debi
Hey Maya,
This recipe looks awesome and I just love carrot cake. Can you just the Splenda baking blend sugar in place of the powdered erythritol? Thank you for sharing this recipe.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Debi, I haven’t tried it but it would probably work. It would not be low carb, sugar-free, or natural, though, because Splenda Baking Blend is 1/2 sugar and sucralose is artificial.
Anetta
Sounds delicious! Can I leave out the walnuts? I’m not a big fan of them in baking! Or do you need them for flavour?
Thanks you!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Anetta! Yes, you can leave out the walnuts. I think it tastes great with or without them. Have a great day!
Diana Cox
Cannot wait to try this…the picture made my mouth water and sounds really easy. I’m wondering if it can be baked in a bundt pan. Thank you.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Diana! Yes, you can make it in a bundt pan. It may affect the baking time, though, and I couldn’t tell you exactly since I haven’t tested it. I hope you get the chance to try and let us know how it goes!
Jane
Hi, I cannot find the list of ingredients for the carrot cake? No ingredients with amounts? Just method? Not sure if I’m missing something? Looks amazing and am super keen to try it out Thank you and many thanks, Jane
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Jane, The ingredients are right on the recipe card. If you see the instructions (method), just scroll up and the ingredients are above that.
Maria O Padron
It sounds and looks good. The carb count for me is to high at 8.5. I follow the total 20 carbs a day. Not much room unless I ate 1/2 of the recommended piece portion.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Maria! Are you eating 20g net carbs or total carbs per day? Many people following keto do net carbs, not counting fiber in the carb count. A piece has 5.5g net carbs. I hope you get the chance to try it!
Maria O Padron
Dear Maya: 5.5gnet carbs sounds better. Yes it’s net carbs. I loved carrot cake before I started the Keto LCHF Woe. Now I don’t have to miss it. Thanks!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you like it, Maria! Have a great day!