Shop
My
Custom
Why I’m Obsessed With This Sugar Free Thousand Island Dressing Recipe
Once I started making this sugar free thousand island dressing recipe at home, I couldn’t believe how easy it was or how much better it tasted than the bottled stuff. I still love my go-to ranch and caesar, but this one hits that sweet-and-tangy craving just right. Plus, it goes with so many things (and yep, I’ve listed some of my favorite ways to use it below!). Here’s why this one’s always in my fridge:
- Creamy, sweet, and tangy – This dressing has that classic flavor combo…rich mayo, tangy vinegar, and a hint of sweetness. It reminds me of the kind I had growing up, just without the sugar or weird ingredients.
- Just 6 ingredients + 5 minutes – I can toss this together in minutes, usually with what I already have on hand. It’s perfect for a quick meal prep win or a last-minute salad.
- Way better than store-bought – Most sugar free dressings at the store either taste off or have hidden junk. I like knowing exactly what’s in mine, and honestly… it tastes fresher, too.
Make it with me and taste the difference!
Ingredients & Substitutions
Here I explain the best ingredients for my sugar free thousand island dressing recipe, what each one does, and substitution options. For measurements, see the recipe card.
- Mayonnaise – I usually whip up my own avocado oil mayo, but store-bought avocado mayo (like this one!) works just fine too.
- Sugar-free ketchup – Same idea. I like to make homemade sugar free ketchup, but you can use a store-bought one instead.
- Apple Cider Vinegar – Adds a little tang, but white vinegar or even lemon juice works in a pinch.
- Sweetener – It has to be powdered or your dressing will turn out gritty. I use Besti Powdered Monk Fruit Allulose Blend because it dissolves the best. Most sweeteners with erythritol don’t mix in well and can crystallize. You can skip it, but the dressing won’t have that classic sweet-tangy balance. If you’re using a different one, check my sweetener conversion chart or just start small and adjust.
- Dill Pickles – Finely chopped dill pickles add that signature flavor. You could also use sugar-free relish if that’s easier.
- White Onion – I go with finely minced white onion, but yellow or even a tiny bit of grated shallot would work too.
- Sea Salt & Black Pepper
FREE 5-Ingredient Recipe EBook
GET IT NOWHow To Make Sugar Free Thousand Island Dressing
There’s just one easy step to make this sugar free thousand island dressing—Just whisk everything together! It’s ready in the time it takes to grab the ingredients.
I like to keep sugar free thousand island dressing in jars like this in the fridge for easy storage, but these salad dressing containers are perfect for meal prep!
My Recipe Tips
- The pickles and onions should be really fine so the dressing is creamy, not chunky. A quick pulse in a food processor works great if you’re in a hurry.
- Granulated sweeteners can make the dressing gritty. I always use Powdered Besti because it dissolves super smoothly.
- If you have time, pop the dressing in the fridge for 30 minutes before serving. It helps the flavors come together and thicken up just a bit.
- Tweak to taste. I sometimes add a tiny splash more vinegar if I want it tangier, or a pinch more sweetener if I’m in the mood for a sweeter version.
Sugar Free Thousand Island Dressing
By
My sugar free thousand island dressing recipe is creamy, tangy, and takes just 5 minutes to make—no sugar, no junk, just simple ingredients!
Instructions
[ See step photos See my tips ]Tap on the times in the instructions to start a kitchen timer.
-
Whisk all ingredients together, until smooth.
Did you make it? Leave a review or tag me @wholesomeyum on Instagram!
Maya’s Recipe Notes
Serving size: 2 tbsp
- Tips: Check out my recipe tips above to help you get the smoothest texture, the best flavor, and a dressing that tastes just like the classic without the sugar.
- Serving ideas: See my serving ideas below for easy ways to use this dressing on burgers, salads, and more.
- Store: Keep in an airtight container in the fridge for 5-7 days.
- Freeze: You can freeze it for 2-3 months, but the texture changes a bit. Thaw in the fridge and whisk before using.
I provide nutrition facts as a courtesy. Have questions about calculations or why you got a different result? Please see my nutrition policy.
Add Your Notes Your Notes
Try More Of My Recipes
© Copyright Maya Krampf for Wholesome Yum. Please DO NOT SCREENSHOT OR COPY/PASTE recipes to social media or websites. We’d LOVE for you to share a link with photo instead.
sugar free thousand island dressing
Serving Ideas
Wondering what to put this sugar free thousand island dressing recipe on? Here are some of my favorite ways to use it:
- Salads – Obviously! It’s the secret sauce in my Big Mac salad, but it’s just as good on a chef salad, or honestly, pretty much any of my healthy salad recipes.
- Burgers – In-N-Out fans, this one’s for you! Whether you’re making juicy burgers, smash burgers, or even turkey burgers, this dressing gives you that classic, old-school burger joint flavor!
- Kid Favorites – This dressing isn’t just for salads! My kids love it as a dip for air fryer chicken tenders and crispy air fryer fries!
48 Comments
Regina
0This is totally delicious. I don’t know when I’ll stop topping my salad with it. I’ve been having a salad every day just so I can enjoy this salad dressing with it. Thanks a million for this recipe!
Belinda Smith
0Delish added some lemon juice about a teaspoon and a half, and used dill relish instead of the pickle very very good
Annette Helms
0Excellent dressing!!
Dee Burr
0I made this recipe. I used Dukes’ mayonaise. I used Aldi’s ketchup with contains no sugar.
I only used 1Tbsp Swerve. This is too sweet Would you know how to calm the sweetness down? If no I’ll have to toss out and try again.
It’s easy to make, just need one that isn’t sweet.
Alissa
0Can I use white vinegar or red wine vinegar? I don’t like apple cider vinegar.
Wholesome Yum M
0Hi Alissa, Yes, either of those will work. Enjoy!
Wholesome Yum M
0Hi Dee, You could make the recipe a second time without the sweetener and mix them together. That should even out the sweetness level.
Maggie
0I don’t have the monk sweetener. Can I replace with swerve?
Wholesome Yum M
0Hi Maggie, Allulose really works best as it can dissolve in liquids where other sweeteners don’t. The brand you have will work, but there may be some grittiness in the dressing. Make sure you are using the powdered version to get the best possible results with what you have.
Tammy
0This recipe promised and delivered! I used as a dipping sauce for chicken and going to try making a Big Mac salad! Love your recipes and just bought your cookbook and Besti product on Amazon!
Lori M.
0This is one of my favorite ways to use up mayo that has been in the fridge a little two long and I find I actually prefer a Big Mac salad to one with bread these days. I like it sweeter so I add a little powdered erythritol sweetener. Raw onion bothers my stomach, so I add some spices to replace the sharpness: onion powder, paprika and garlic powder. Sugar free sweet pickles are good too, esp. homemade fridge pickles with stevia. Condiments are such overcharged (when compared to ingredients) hidden sugar purchases! Learning from you with regards to mayo, catsup and coconut aminos has me making so many condiments like 1000 Island dressing, tartar sauce (with lime), BBQ sauce and teriyaki sauce. They are fresh, sugar free, sodium-reduced and overall more organic at reasonable prices with acids in less contact with plastic/resins and other hidden estrogens. Thank you for your ongoing expertise.
Judy
0Is it a big difference if I leave out dill pickle? I need to cut sodium, I don’t want to buy a whole jar just for a small amount of chopped dill pickle.
I do have an opened jar of capers, Can I sub that?
Heather Kuhn
0Okay, I really want to know how the capers turned out because I loathe pickles.
Wholesome Yum M
0Hi Judy, Obviously the overall flavor will be different if you omit the pickle. I think capers would make a great replacement for the pickle. Enjoy!
Maria
0I want to Thank You For FREE Recipes, I Love❤it. God Blessed
Jere Cassidy
0I haven’t had Thousand Island dressing for years, I think the store-bought kind just didn’t taste great. This makes me want to make a salad right now with your dressing on top.
Beth
0This is so delicious! This is my new go to recipe for 1000 Island!
Chloe
0This came together so fast and was good, it’s definitely going to become a regular in my meal prep rotation!
Nart at Cooking with Nart
0Thousand island dressing is amazing. Love that yours is low carb!