This post may contain affiliate links. I may earn a small commission from purchases made through them, at no additional cost to you, which helps keep this content free. (Full disclosure)
One of the consequences of food blogging is that you are always testing recipes way ahead of the time when they’ll be appropriate. Posting them early gives people a chance to see them before an occasion or season arrives. This one is a prime example. I made this easy leftover turkey casserole recipe with mayonnaise in October!
Fortunately, we actually eat turkey a few times a year, anyway. So, I didn’t mind the excuse to experiment with easy leftover turkey recipes. Even if that means eating turkey leftovers in October! It’s a good thing my family loves them.
I made this low carb leftover turkey casserole recipe a month in advance. That way, it will be ready for you by the time you need turkey leftover recipes after Thanksgiving. (Yes, that’s only a few weeks away!) In the meantime, you can easily try it using shredded chicken, if you don’t have turkey around.
The first time I made this Thanksgiving leftover casserole, I got the following comment from my husband: “A casserole? I hate casseroles. But this one is really, really good. Like really good.” Yay!
Nevermind the fact that I’m pretty sure he doesn’t actually hate casseroles. (Who hates casseroles?!) For one, he never once complained about the loaded cauliflower casserole I made recently. But, with this one I got positive feedback without even asking. My daughter kept asking for more, too!
I can’t wait to make this easy turkey casserole again after Thanksgiving.
Deciding What To Do With Leftover Turkey
When I thought about what to make with turkey leftovers, I instantly knew I’d be making a casserole. That’s pretty much always the answer when trying to figure out what to do with leftovers! Casseroles are simple and you can throw in whatever you have on hand. Turkey leftovers are no exception.
Sure, you could probably make a soup or sandwich with your leftover turkey. But, the advantage of a casserole is that you can use up multiple things from your Thanksgiving table. So convenient!
Besides, I’m a huge fan of low carb casseroles. They are pure comfort food and the whole family will enjoy them.
This one is no exception. It’s savory, cheesy, and tangy all at the same time. You’ll love the flavor combination of turkey, cranberries, green beans, and cheese!
If you still have leftovers after this one, you can freeze them. To freeze, you can assemble the whole thing and just throw it in the oven when ready to eat. You don’t even have to defrost it!
The same applies if you’re just sick of turkey by the time Thanksgiving week is over, and want to enjoy it later. Just freeze it if you’re bored with turkey right after the holiday. That’s hard to imagine now before it has even started, but you know we’ve all been there!
Turkey Leftover Casserole Ingredients
The best leftover turkey recipes are quick, easy, and will use up whatever Thanksgiving leftovers you have. The way I see it, the main options have to do with what you have left and what you’ll use to tie everything together.
After all, I’m willing to bet it won’t be only turkey that you’ll be looking to use up. Often times, people have green beans, cranberry sauce, or stuffing left over, too.
This is why my turkey leftover casserole recipe also includes green beans and healthy sugar-free cranberry sauce. I pretty much always have some of these around after Thanksgiving is over!
In fact, this entire casserole consists of things I always have around at that time. And, you can easily adjust the amounts of each ingredient based on how much you have. Isn’t that the point of leftover Thanksgiving recipes?
I used plain cooked green beans with some sea salt, but it would work equally well by layering your favorite green bean casserole into it.
Other than the green beans, turkey, and cranberry sauce, I just threw in some other common ingredients. It’s just cheddar cheese, garlic and mayonnaise for the filling, then goat cheese and (optional) walnuts for the topping. You can leave out the walnuts if you don’t have them or are nut-free, but they do add a nice crunch.
Can You Make It a Turkey Stuffing Casserole?
So, why doesn’t this Thanksgiving leftover casserole contain stuffing? For me, the main reason was that my cauliflower stuffing recipe wasn’t ready yet when I created this. (Stay tuned – it’s coming in a few days!)
That doesn’t mean you shouldn’t add stuffing. You can definitely add a layer of stuffing to your leftover turkey casserole, if you have some left.
I’ll probably add my low carb cauliflower stuffing to this next time I make it. I’m certain that it would be delicious with or without it. If you have a different recipe you make, feel free to throw that in!
That’s one of the best things about this Thanksgiving leftover casserole – it’s so versatile!
Why This is a Healthy Leftover Turkey Casserole
This is a great option for anyone looking for healthy leftover turkey casserole recipes. It’s naturally low carb (if using my low carb cranberry sauce) and gluten-free, plus it’s packed with vegetables. And, it’s still filling and comforting at the same time.
If you prefer to use Greek yogurt instead of mayonnaise, that’s an easy swap to make. Doing this will make it lower in fat but a little higher in carbs. I prefer the mayo version, but both are good.
Being the planner that I am, it’s nice that I already decided on what to do with leftover turkey after our Thanksgiving festivities.
Even though we don’t usually host the holiday at our house, we have lots of turkey with our families. I know they will send us home with extra turkey leftovers. They always do! If you’re from the U.S., chances are you’ll have some around next month, too.
I hope you’ll save this low carb leftover turkey casserole recipe and give it a try!
Easy Leftover Turkey Casserole Recipe With Mayonnaise:
Pin it to save for later!
(Click the button above to open the pin, then click "Save" to save it to a board.)
Want more low carb, gluten-free casseroles? Try these: