KETO
KETO
MEAL PLAN
FREE PRINTABLE: LOW CARB & KETO FOOD LIST!
Join 200,000+ others to get a FREE keto food list, plus weekly keto recipes!
GET IT NOWThis post may contain affiliate links, which help keep this content free. (Full disclosure)
It’s officially the first week of fall! Are you making everything pumpkin yet? The Midwest has been having its usual identity crisis, alternating cool, rainy days with hot, humid ones. That’s not stopping me from being in a pumpkin mood, though. I already made healthy pumpkin muffins a couple weeks ago. This week, I’m testing pumpkin bars and finalized this keto low carb pumpkin pie.
With the holidays coming up, you’ll need a good sugar-free pumpkin pie recipe! The nice thing about this one is, it tastes like a regular pumpkin pie, so the whole family will eat it. I served pumpkin pie cupcakes last year, but this time I think I’ll try a real, full sized pie.
Options for Easy Keto Pumpkin Pie
My top priority for an easy low carb pumpkin pie was for it to be as simple as possible. Complicated desserts are just not for me. The good news is, it was actually really easy to make a pumpkin pie recipe sugar-free. All I had to do is use a low carb crust and sweetener.
The version I came up with uses common ingredients, which is nice. The only one that is possibly less common is the powdered sweetener, but if you do even a little low carb baking you’ll probably have that one around. If not, you could also run any granulated sweetener through a food processor until it has a powdered consistency.
The keto pumpkin pie filling has only five ingredients, plus optional vanilla extract and molasses. Both of these add a lot of flavor, so I recommend including them if you can. The carbs they contribute are negligible, since the amount is so small and spread across the entire recipe.
You can make this into a paleo pumpkin pie by using coconut cream instead of heavy cream. That’s an easy substitution. Other than that, if you need another sweetener to consider it paleo-friendly, that’s not a problem. Something like coconut sugar should work just fine, preferably ground up to a finer consistency.
Sugar-Free Pumpkin Pie with Almond Flour Crust
Ever since I posted my favorite almond flour pie crust recipe, I’ve been looking for every excuse under the sun to use it. So, even though I considered a coconut flour crust, I decided to go with almond so that I could use that recipe again. You can swap it with your favorite crust if you prefer a different one.
Regardless of what crust you choose, you’ll want to pre-bake it first, so that it doesn’t get soggy once you add the filling. You will probably want to cover the crust edges with foil when baking the pie with filling. That way, the crust won’t burn.
For an easy way to cover the crust, simply cut a square of aluminum foil larger than the pie, fold it in fourths, then cut a quarter circle from one corner of the square. Unfold it, and viola! You’ll have foil edges with a hole in the middle. Just place it over your sugar-free pumpkin pie when you bake the filling, fold over the edges, and the crust won’t burn.
How To Make Low Carb Pumpkin Pie Without Cracks
Other than that, the only real trick to keto pumpkin pie is just like the regular kind – do not over bake it. Remember that it’s a custard, in some ways similar to low carb cheesecake. You’ll want to take it out of the oven when it’s still jiggly. Over-baking will cause cracks and affects the texture.
You could also bake the pie in a water bath to reduce chances of cracking. The reason cracks form is because the outside cooks before the center sets, and the filling shrinks as it cools, creating cracks. The water bath keeps the outside from cooking too fast, so it’s less likely to crack.
I have to admit, the water bath is a little more hassle, so I usually skip that step. It just depends on how carefully you’ll be able to watch it and how important the appearance is. This recipe bakes the filling at a lower temperature, which also helps to avoid the cracks.
And hey, if your low carb pumpkin pie does develop cracks, just cover ’em with some whipped cream! No one will ever know. 😉
Easy Keto Low Carb Pumpkin Pie Recipe (Sugar-Free, Gluten-Free):
Pin it to save for later!
Reader Favorite Recipes
The recipe card is below! Readers also made these similar recipes after making this one.
Tools To Make Keto Pumpkin Pie:
Click the links below to see the items used to make this recipe.
- Hand mixer – For beating your filling. This one is powerful but also has the lower settings you’ll need for this keto pumpkin pie recipe.
- Pie server – This one has a nice grippy handle.
- 9-inch Pie Pan – Of course you need a pie pan for your keto friendly pumpkin pie! This is the one I used.
- Non-stick pie crust shield – If your crust starts to burn before the filling is ready to take out of the oven, use this. Another option is a silicone shield like this.
- Pumpkin pie spice – A blend like this saves time if you don’t want to make your own.
- Powdered erythritol blend or powdered monk fruit blend – Either of these two will work for this low carb pumpkin pie recipe!
RECIPE CARD
Go Ad-Free
Easy Keto Low Carb Pumpkin Pie Recipe (Sugar-Free, Gluten-Free)
Recipe Video
Click or tap on the image below to play the video. It's the easiest way to learn how to make this recipe!
PrintIngredients
Click underlined ingredients to see where to get them.
Please ensure Safari reader mode is OFF to view ingredients.
Get Keto Sweetener For This Recipe
Meet Besti Monk Fruit Allulose Blend, the keto sweetener that tastes, bakes, dissolves, and browns just like sugar, with NO aftertaste and 0 net carbs.
GET BESTIInstructions
Get RECIPE TIPS in the post above, nutrition info + recipe notes below!
Click on the times in the instructions below to start a kitchen timer while you cook.
- Make the sweet almond flour pie crust according to the directions here.
- Meanwhile, beat together all remaining ingredients at medium-low speed, until smooth. (Don't overmix.)
-
When the pie crust is done baking, reduce the oven temperature to 325 degrees F (163 degrees C). Cool the crust on the counter for at least 10 minutes, longer if you have time.
- Pour the filling into the crust. Gently tap on the counter to release air bubbles.
-
Bake for 40-50 minutes, until the pie is almost set but still slightly jiggly in the center. (Check on it occasionally, and if you see the crust start to brown, cover the crust edge with foil and return to the oven until the filling is done. It should still jiggle a bit in the center, like a custard before it sets.)
-
Cool completely on the counter, then refrigerate at least an hour before slicing. Pie can be refrigerated overnight.
Readers Also Made These Similar Recipes
Made this? Leave a rating!
Share your recipe picture with @wholesomeyum or #wholesomeyum on Instagram or in our Facebook support group, too - I'd love to see it!
Recipe Notes
To reduce the chance of cracking your low carb pumpkin pie, you can bake the pie in a water bath. Otherwise, if you end up with cracks, you can always cover them with whipped cream.
Serving size: 1 slice, or 1/12 of entire pie
Video Showing How To Make Keto Pumpkin Pie:
Don't miss the VIDEO above - it's the easiest way to learn how to make Keto Pumpkin Pie!
Want some moral support or recipe help?
Nutrition Information Per Serving
Where does nutrition info come from? Nutrition facts are provided as a courtesy, sourced from the USDA Food Database. You can find individual ingredient carb counts we use in the Low Carb & Keto Food List. Net carb count excludes fiber, erythritol, and allulose, because these do not affect blood sugar in most people. (Learn about net carbs here.) We try to be accurate, but feel free to make your own calculations.
Want to save this recipe?
Create a free account to save your favourites recipes and articles!
Sign Up To Save RecipesMore Low Carb Resources
If you want to know more about how to start a low carb diet, want to substitute sweeteners, need a food list, or need support, check these guides:
How To Start Keto 
Keto Sweetener Guide 
Macro Calculator 
Keto Food List Printable
© Copyright Maya Krampf for Wholesome Yum. Please DO NOT SCREENSHOT OR COPY/PASTE recipes to social media or websites. We'd LOVE for you to share a link with photo instead. 🙂
Shop My Must-Have Keto Ingredients
Use the buttons below to buy my new Besti sweeteners and Wholesome Yum keto ingredients, developed by me personally!
Get the full low carb pantry shopping list, browse low carb product discounts, and visit my Amazon Shop!
237 Comments
Jennifer K Johnson
Amazing
Patricia Dwyer-Simpson
I was hoping for a recipe for FRESH pumpkin pie. I always bake my Halloween pumpkins ( not carved), slice them and then scrape out the pumpkin . I cannot find a recipe that uses a fresh pumpkin for a pie All the recipes use canned pumpkin. Is there a way to actually make the fresh the same consistency as the canned version?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Patricia, If you already know how to roast and puree your fresh pumpkins, then you have all you need for this recipe! This pumpkin pie recipe works well with canned or fresh pumpkin. The recipe specifically uses canned pumpkin because it’s readily available in any grocery store.
Lindsay Adams
This recipe was out of this world! Hand down, best keto pumpkin pie I’ve ever had!! 5 out of 5 recommended!
Elizabeth Vose
I put half as much sweetener in but, otherwise, followed the recipe exactly. One of my favorite keto friendly desserts. Thank you for sharing it.
Joan
I got it… my monk fruit powdered sweetener had to be entered manually, it was not subtracting sugar alcohols… Thank you, That was bugging me but now it matches your nutrition…. LOVE the pie!
Joan Devine
Hi, I love this recipe but wonder how you calculate the net carbs… in both the chronometer and my fitness pal I get net 14 carbs… Can’t figure out what I’m doing wrong…
Zella Falcon Cook
I made this and loved it! It got me through Thanksgiving without feeling deprived! And it’s so delicious I am making it again. This time in little ramekins to help with portion control…it’s THAT good! Thank you!!
Erika
This was absolutely delicious!! My kids even loved it! First pumpkin pie we’ve ever tried and this gets 5 stars! Only swap was I made a pecan pie crust instead of almond flour. This is a keeper- THANK YOU!!
Jennae
Hi, we made this pie last night and it was delicious. My only worry/complaint is the texture of the pie is super goopy. We set it in the oven for 50min and cooled it in the fridge for an hour. Even after it being in the fridge all night, there was a lot of liquid on the bottom from where a piece was cut. Doesn’t have the same texture as typical pumpkin pie. Is it supposed to be that way? Or should I have baked it longer? I’d like to make this again but have a more solid/firm pie.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Jannae, It sounds like your pie should have baked longer in the oven. When you remove it, it should be jiggly in the center and set along the outsides by the crust. If this was not how it looked, then it would need to bake longer in the oven.
Lisa Tabor
This was my first Keto Thanksgiving and I was so afraid that this wouldn’t measure up to my “usual” pumpkin pie…but I was SO wrong. This was fantastic and easy. It’s the first time I’ve ever made my own pie crust…and while the crust wasn’t perfect, it WAS delicious!! Thank you Maya…you NEVER disappoint!!
Louann
This was wonderful. Closest to the traditional taste that I’ve found. Thanks!
yvonne brents henson
my pie does not taste quite right — it is not good — what did i do wrong? I followed your recipe except for the pumpkin pie spice, i like to make my own.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Yvonne, I would love to help you troubleshoot, but I need a little more information. What about your pie wasn’t good? Flavor, texture, consistency? Can you describe the flavor you got from it?
Teresa
I made this for my family today, and we loved it! Even my 7-year-old grandson ate every bite of his and wanted more. I will definitely be using the crust for other dishes, but it will be difficult to top this pairing of a perfect pumpkin custard with an amazingly tender keto crust. I stuck very close to the recipe (which is unlike me), and I’m really glad I did. The one option I used on the crust was to add cinnamon, and it was a great choice. Thank you for helping us keep our keto diet so deliciously!
Ermeess Rivera Faris
Oh my, this was amazing. Nobody found out it was low carb. Thank you
Marilyn
This is a good recipe. But Its really sweet. I made a double batch for 2 pies. I’ll bet i could use 1/2 – 3/4 of the sweetener
Melissa
I’ve been baking for 50mins and it it still watery.
Did I do something wrong?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Melissa, Is it watery or not set? The center should still be jiggly when you remove it from the oven, but if it’s fully liquid then it will need to bake for longer.
Judy
Loved this pie! Thank you. You helped me enjoy preparing for Thanksgiving. Will be easy to in a healthy way.
Amber
Very good recipe! I actually use it to make mini pie bites instead of a whole pie. I experimented with it last year and it turned out great so this time I paid attention to times so I could share. I made the pie crust recipe mostly to recipe but I used sucralose sugar substitute that is available at my local Aldi. Then instead of pushing it into a 9 inch pie pan, I lined a 24 cupcake tin with paper wrappers. I put 1 level tablespoon of the crust into each one. I pressed it flat into the bottom and poked with a fork then pre baked for 10 minutes. I made the filling to recipe but used the same sucralose as in the crust. I put around 1 and a half tablespoons of filling in each spot. Tapped out the air and baked for around 30 minutes. These little pumpkin pie bites are a huge hit! And since each one is 1/24 of the recipe, they are only 2g net carbs each!
EM
If I don’t have powdered erythritol or powdered monk fruit could I use droplets of monk fruit sweetener? Thanks 🙂
Wholesome Yum M
Hi EM, I am sorry, I have not tested this recipe with liquid sweetener, and am not sure if it will work.
Sister Rosemary Cuneo
I just took my pie out of the oven. Looks delicious. No cracks. But the pie is starting to get white spots on the surface as it cools, looks like mold. I used all fresh ingredients and followed your recipe exactly. Did I miss something?
Thank you for your feedback. Will need to cover the pie with whipped cream.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Sister Rosemary, The white spots are likely due to the powdered sweetener. It will still taste delicious.
robin
same thing happened to me, but still tasted good
Tammie
My poor has been in the oven for 85 minutes at 350 and it’s still not cooked through – I treat it with a knife which comes out covered in custard – it tastes great but why won’t it set???
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Tammie, The pie should not fully be set when you pull it from the oven. 85 minutes is far too long for it to still be liquid in the center. Is it possible that you skipped the eggs in the recipe?
Ruth Anne Martinez
Hello, I’m trying to make some keto friendly, gluten-free, dairy-free, sugar-free desserts and dishes for my in-laws for Thanksgiving. I live a keto lifestyles, my sister-in-law is strict on gluten-free and dairy-free, and my brother-in-law is sugar-free. For anything that requires butter or ghee, can I replace it with butter flavored coconut oil?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Ruth, Yes! Butter flavored coconut oil will work in place of butter or ghee! Enjoy your holiday!
T
Hi! I was reading the ingredients of the pumpkin purée and it has 4 grams of sugar, so this pumpkin pie isn’t sugar free and has more than two grams of sugar than the listed ingredients. Any way for clarification 🙂 I’ve been trying to find a sugar free keto pumpkin pie to make but it looks like this isn’t sugar free as it states in the title.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi T, The sugar in this pumpkin is natural sugars from the pumpkin itself. It does not contain any additional ingredients. Any pumpkin puree will have some natural sugars in it.
Cynthia McClanahan
My absolute favorite recipe! I’m ready to make again, I do not have heavy cream. Would almond milk be too much difference?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Cynthia, I would use coconut cream if you don’t have or want to use heavy cream. I don’t think almond milk will give the same creamy result.
Herman
Recipe turned out great, but I’m the only one eating it. Can I cut into individual servings and freeze? I’m eating 1/12 a day. Thanks
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Herman, Yes, that would work great!
Herman
Thanks!
Beckyas123
I made the crust as instructed and the recipe with fresh pumpkin and Monkfruit sweetener and let me say….it is absolutely delicious! I did have to increase cooking time by about 10 minutes but then it was perfect. Soooooo happy to have this recipe just in time for the holidays. I plan to make 3 more and freeze them.
Jana
I doubled the filling recipe and it was pretty thick. The only change I made – I used 1 cup of almond cooking milk (like evaporated milk but almond) instead of 1 cup or cream. It was thicker than regular pumpkin pie filling. Otherwise, everything was doubled (big can of pumpkin, double powdered sweetener, spices, eggs, etc). Is your filling quite thick when you put into crust or more like a regular? Wondering if I should have added more of this cooking milk to thin it out… I’ll let you know how it turns out! It’s baking now…
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Jana, Using a large can of pumpkin actually shorts you 1 oz of pumpkin puree in the recipe. A regular-sized can of pumpkin is 15 oz, and a large can is 29 oz. Sp from that, I would speculate that your filling needed a little more liquid. I am not familiar with the almond cooking milk you referred to, so I don’t know the consistency or thickness of it. Please let me know how it comes out.
M.
Really surprised how this turned out! I made a small pie with half of this recipe. I was a bit lazy and just roughly estimated all the ingredients. It turned out wonderful! Very easy and worthwhile recipe. My mother doesn’t like pumpkin whatever, but she practically inhaled this cake :). I used 200 gram oven-fresh pumpkin that I baked in the oven until soft (for the whole recipe it should be 400 grams).
Thank you so much for this recipe! I’m on a low carb diet for almost a year now and have tried many desserts before. This one stands out!
Cath
I just made this, and it is delicious! I skipped the crust entirely and baked it in a greased (buttered) glass baking dish. I didn’t have heavy cream so I used 10% cream and it was fine. This will be my fall pumpkin pudding dessert until further notice!
Ruth Anne Martinez
Hello, I am thinking about making a crustless version too. So everything turned out perfect?
Korneliabrown
Oh MY GOODNESS, I BAKED THIS PIE AND JUST HAD A PIECE, ITS SOOOO GOOD. I’M GLAD I FOUND THIS RECIPE FOR THANKSGIVING, SINCE MY HUBBY JUST GOT DIAGNOSED WITH PRE DIABETES. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
Taffy
I made this using Pecan Flour for crust. So delicious!
Kasia
Can I make this pie a couple of days ahead? Will it keep well in the fridge? I’d like to make it for Thanksgiving but won’t have the time on day of and even a day before…
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Kasia, Yes, you can make this pie a couple of days in advance. It will keep well in the refrigerator.
Cecilia
Where I live they don’t have pumpkin in a can. What do I do then, please?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Cecilia, You can roast your own pie pumpkin if you have access to fresh pumpkins. Cut the pumpkin in half, scoop out the seeds, score the outside with a knife, and roast at 350 degrees F. The bake time will vary with the size of your pumpkin, but you’ll know when it’s done when you can easily pierce the outside of the pumpkin with a fork. I hope this helps!
Althe
I just made this pie for the first time and it didn’t set well for me. I made the almond flour crust and let it set for well over 10 mins before filling. However, 50 mins later and an hour of cooling and it’s not fully set. Although I did forget to put it in the fridge. I’m cooking it a little longer and then going to cool and refrigerate. But what could I have done wrong?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Althe, How loose was the pie when you pulled it from the oven? Was it mostly set with the center slightly jiggly? If the whole top was jiggly, then it could have used more time in the oven. The bake times are guidelines, as every oven can vary slightly in temperature with hot and cold spots. If your pie was correctly set, then it needed to cool, then go straight to the fridge, where it would fully set. Refrigeration is a key step for a custard-style pie. I hope this helps!
Lyn
Helllooooo! I just put this together and about to pop in in the oven. Too lazy to make the crust, so just making it like a pudding, then sprinkled some Lily’s Choc Chips on top. I was a little scared it will burn on the bottom, so it’s sitting in a hot water bath like you would bake a cheesecake. My hopes are high that it will turn out, I know the flavor will be fabulous, cuz it’s one of your recipes!!
Anna
Hello,
I added half a teaspoon of xanthan gum to crust and it came out perfectly sturdy with no crumbling issues.
If you like a less sweet pie, I added half the sweetener and it still worked great!
My diabetic partner was so happy to have a comfort food he could eat!!
Ms Anastasia Fforde
Worked so well, thank you for great recipe. One thing the website on the phone is so hard to read, a lot of pop up windows!
Melissa
I’ve made this pie (and crust) a few times. It’s always been fantastic! Today I accidentally forgot to add the heavy cream to the pie filling. And realized too late… here’s hoping it still works out!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Melissa, The crust will be a little dense, but it should still work.
Mary
The pie certainly tasted good, but next time I will use parchment paper as the crust started to burn. Also, when I put the pie in the fridge, I noticed the top had a thin while layer on it. Wonder if the butter came through the crust and hardened on the surface of the pie?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Mary, If you crust was still slightly oily when you removed it from the oven, then I would assume you are correct about the butter hardening on top.
Deb
My second time making this. It is so delicious!
Julia
I’ve made this pie a handful of times. My husband and son love it. The only issue I have is with the crust, it either separates from the pie or falls apart after I cut it and try to get the slice out of the pan. Do you have any thoughts on why this could be happening? Also, what is the best thing to use to grease the pan “well” for the crust? Thank you for all of your delicious recipes!!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Julia, I haven’t experienced that but you could add about 1/4 tsp xanthan gum to the crust to make it a bit more sturdy and less crumbly. I usually grease with butter or coconut oil, but any other neutral oil would work too.
Ruth Carpenter
Just a fyi… I’ve been using sweet potato puree in place of pumpkin, and with pumpkin pie spice, vanilla, and a dash of molasses, it doesn’t need any sweetener at all.
Keira
Usually love the recipes on this site but this pumpkin pie NEVER set! I followed the instructions exactly and baked as directed and it’s like a baked pie crust with canned pumpkin in the middle. Very disappointed.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Keira, Did you chill it afterward? Like all custard-based pies, it’s not meant to fully set in the oven and should set after chilling in the fridge.
Larry A Wurdeman
This was extremely sweet! Not my idea of pumpkin pie. I did not add sweetener to the crust.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Larry, Typically pumpkin pie is pretty sweet (and to me this one is less sweet than store bought ones), but feel free to reduce sweetener if you don’t like how sweet it is.
Aaron
Love this recipe. I sometimes do 1/4 cup coconut yogurt, and 1/4 unsweetened almond milk instead of the half cup of heavy cream. Look at the sweetener you have, if might need to be reduced further of it’s equivalent to 2 x regular sugar.
Deb
I made this for Thanksgiving today. It is delicious! Thank you very much for the recipe.
Kandi
So pleasantly surprised! I loooove pumpkin pie and everything about this keto recipe is fantastic. I made one to try the recipe out before Thanksgiving and I expected it to be about 50% pumpkin pie like, but it’s about 95% exactly like traditional pumpkin pie. My father in law told me he couldn’t even tell a difference. Thank you for this recipe! ❤️
Mindy Van Houten
Do you think I could use Swerve brown sugar in this recipe? I don’t have any molasses. Thank you and love your recipes!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Mindy, Sure! I think that would work out just fine if you sub the molasses with brown erythritol.
Cindy
The pie turned out perfect except that it turned slightly white. I used the organic erythritol powder and followed your recipe. What would have caused this?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Cindy, The powdered form of sweetener is most likely the culprit here. I’m sure it still tastes delicious!
Julia
I have made this pie a handful of times and it’s delicious my husband and son love it. I have yet to perfect the crust though. The past couple of times I’ve made it 2 things have happened. The pie filling moved away from the back of the crust and the filling was a bit too loose. Do you have any tips on how to make the pie a little more firm and stop the back of the crust from separating? Also, what is the molasses for, color, texture, or taste?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Julia, If the filling has been too loose for you in the past, then I suggest you add another egg to your next filling. That should help with the filling and crust separation as well. The molasses is for flavor. Although it is optional, the caramel flavor it provides adds a lot of depth to this pumpkin pie.
Tanya
Can you please tell me the recipe? I cant find it on your article:(
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Tanya, The recipe is above where it says “Recipe card” in big letters. You can also use the “jump to recipe” button at the top.
Maureen
I really don’t like using erythritol; it upsets my gut. Could I just use a few drops of liquid monk fruit sweetener instead of the Swerve in this recipe?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Maureen, I think that will work in this recipe.
Amy
You mentioned (blanched) almond flour. Is that the best way or is regular almond flour ok?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Amy, I recommend blanched almond flour.
Holly
I started mixing the ingredients together before I noticed that it required powdered erythritol – I only had the granulated on hand so I used that and just a bit less. I also used the new Pre made low carb pecan crust it came out delicious! The portion size is perfect.
Nikki
We are allergic to eggs. Would an egg replacement work? What would you recommend? thanks!!
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Nikki, Yes, an egg replacement should work fine with this recipe.
Tara
I pureed a jack o lantern instead of using canned. I also made my own pie spice. The pie was good using my substitutions but mostly crust and mild flavor.
Adrienne Reiser
This is a delicious recipe and satisfies my cravings for a pumpkin desert. While the family is eating their pumpkin pie, I can eat mine. I like less crust in my pies so I split the dough recipe into two balls and froze one to be used a couple of weeks later. It was perfect for me! 5 Stars!
Kim Lewis
Great recipe, tasted just like the real thing. Does anyone know if this pie can be frozen? I’ll be out of town for Thanksgiving and would love to take this with me.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Kim, Yes, you can freeze it!
Athena
I just made this recipe on Saturday morning along with the almond crust. OMG! It is so good. It tastes just as good as traditional pumpkin pie. Thank you for this recipe. I can’t wait to try some of your others.
Karen
Does the nutritional info include the almond crust? If so, can I factor it out since I used a different crust?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Karen, Yes, the nutrition info includes the almond flour crust. You can calculate your own nutrition info and factor it out if you used something else.
Danielle
Mine didn’t set. I’m wondering if it’s because my eggs weren’t room temperate? I’m going to try it again. But the crust was awesome!
Lisa
I am in the middle of baking one now. It’s been in for an hour and doesn’t look like it’s done. I stuck a knife in like I usually do for pumpkin pie and it doesn’t come out clean. But what’s on the knife tastes good. Not sure what I’m doing wrong?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Lisa, A knife won’t come out clean when it’s done, I would not use that as a test. It’s done when it’s jiggly in the center but less so on the edges. It will fully set after chilling.
Jessica
This pie was amazing! Such a success at Thanksgiving, the family raved about it and were shocked that it was keto. I used the almond flour crust from this site as my crust, and the only other substitution was instead of canned pumpkin, I used pumpkin from my garden (a bonus). Both tasty and the appropriate texture – a win!
Chaswiss
I imagine using fresh pumpkins you only need to take the flesh and puree it right?
Jessica Gaber
I roasted it first actually to make the flesh soft – cut it in half, roasted it for a while, scooped it out and a quick puree – then it’s basically the same as the canned version (but fresher!)
Lin
How much regular sugar can I use instead of the sweetener? Brown/white sugar?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Lin, I don’t recommend regular sugar for a low carb pie (it would no longer be low carb), but the sweetener conversion would technically be a similar amount.
Kim
If you don’t want it to be low carb, I would suggest using the Libby’s recipe. Can’t beat it. But this recipe comes really close. It’s my go-to when I’m craving pumpkin, which is all year round. 🙂
Jan
I love pumpkin season! All of my pie plates are 10″ plates. Can you tell me what % increase I would need to make for that size or what # of servings to change that to? I suspect I would also have to bake a little longer.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Jan, Increase the servings from 12 to 13 and it should accommodate a 10″ pie pan. Best wishes!
Tonya Grundt
Would this recipe work for pumpkin tarts?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Tonya, Sure! The bake time will be shorter, but it will work fine.
Tammie
Oh my gosh! Please help! I just checked my pie after 50 minutes and it’s still liquid consistency. Oh no, what did I do wrong? I followed directions exactly,
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Tammie, Your pie should not be fully set. The center should still be jiggly. You can leave your pie in the oven longer if need be. Some ovens can vary with temperatures and some have hot and cold spots. Just be sure to keep a close eye on it and make sure it isn’t fully setting in the center.
Suzanne Marek
Can you tell me if the 8 carbs per slice includes the crust?
Wholesome Yum A
It includes crust, Suzanne!
Georgie
I absolutely enjoyed this recipe, both the crust and the pie. I actually had been processing a bunch of butternut squash and used it instead of pumpkin. Although carb count is a bit higher I adjust portion size. I also added extra spices as I am a huge “fall spice” kind of girl lol. I also made sugar-free homemade whipped topping. It was awesome!!! Thanks so much!!!
Asad
Tried this recipe this Easter, and it turned out beautifully. I used 2/3 Cup Monk Fruit Sweetener and 1 Tbsp Honey instead of Molasses. Cinnamon, Nutmeg, All Spice (instead of Pumpkin Pie Spice Mix).
Could hardly tell it wasn’t made with a standard pie crust and sugar.
Fabulous recipe! Thank-you!
Eric
Hi! Would this work with allulose? I don’t like using erythritol.
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Eric, Allulose will give a softer pie texture. I think it will work but would add an extra egg to the filling.
Anu
This is WONDERFUL! I made this as is using the almond flour crust, and left out the back strap molasses as I didn’t have any. I also added 1/8 tsp of Stevia and 1/8 tsp of monk fruit sweetener as I was making this for work, and it turned out delicious. I also had to freeze it after I baked it (loooong story lol) so it only got served a couple of weeks after I made it but it thawed beautifully in the fridge, no problems there! Thank you so much for a gorgeous recipe, I’m going to make this a lot
Faith Evans
There was too strong a flavor of spice. When I tasted the batter it was great. After baking it the flavor was overpowering pumpkin pie spice flavor.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Faith, The potency can vary depending on the pumpkin pie spice you use. If yours is very potent, you might need to use less.
Ann
Ahhh I see now that in the linked crust recipe you recommend a couple brands that have 2 net carbs per 1/4 cup serving, so that drastically reduces the carb count! Thank you for linking to these products – I had no idea that there were brands of almond flour that were so low in carbs – I have been sticking with coconut flour since I thought the almond flour was too high for our macros. Thanks again – will be getting the rest of the ingredients to make this for my hubby who was so sad to go without pumpkin pie in Thanksgiving! 🙂
Jenny Winstead
I just finished off the last piece(s) of the pie I made for Thanksgiving. It was wonderful and tastes like the “real” thing. My advice to others trying it …make sure to roll out the dough and then place on the pie plate. It will make it more crust like. I tried it right in the plate and it came out more crumbly. Still amazing though!! Thank you for the recipe!
K Brown
My question is- who the heck cuts a pie, a 9 inch pie in 12 pieces?! Nobody! Nobody but someone who is trying to convince people thay have less calories and carbs. Get real.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
This is what I do all the time and it’s plenty for people I’ve served it for – the pie is quite rich. But, feel free to cut it into any number of pieces you like!
A
I have no issue with the servings and simply up the nutrition if I want a generous 8 servings 😉
Thanks for the awesome website and great recipes!
Patricia
Hi Maya your pumpkin pie recipe is yummy!!! Just wondering what to do with the leftover coconut cream ?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Patricia, Coconut cream is great to replace any dairy application. Coffee, curry, and smoothies are all great!
Tara
I just made chocolate pots de cream pie and ate a 1/12th slice because It’s a very rich, decadent, dense, creamy custard/truffle filling with almond flour/coconut shred crust. While I made a blackberry clafoutis and cut that in 1/8th slices because it is lighter. I think it just depends on the desert and how big a person’s sweet tooth is. I think 1/12th is good for rich pies and 1/8 for lighter ones. I think also when using alternative sweeteners for sweet treats, smaller servings are better… From my experience anyway. Slice it any way you want but pies will still have calories and carbs on the high end.
Ashley
Just made this pie for Thanksgiving and it was AMAZING!!! Tasted just like regular pumpkin pie. Will definitely be adding this to our holiday meals from now on. Thanks so much!
Ashley
Just tried this recipe for Thanksgiving and it was AMAZING!!! It tasted just like regular pumpkin pie. Will definitely be adding this pie to our traditional holiday meals from now on. Thank you so much!
Patti
This was so good! And the crust! Amazing! It was great for our Thanksgiving and it’s definitely a keeper! Thank you so much for your awesome recipes!
Nicole
I made this for thanksgiving and it was a hit! Left the molasses out and baked an additional 10 min and it was perfect! I will be making this year round for sure!!
Amber
This was a big hit at Thanksgiving!! Thank you for the recipe.
Sherry
I used this filling recipe for Thanksgiving dessert, and my husband had no idea that the pumpkin pie was sugar free and low carb. It was delicious! I never did get the jiggle effect and was a bit skeptical, but after being refrigerated overnight, it was a perfectly “normal” looking pumpkin pie. This one is on my permanent recipe list!
Brenna Prentice
Perfect recipe for thanksgiving!! With it being pumpkin, I get the whole pie to myself!!! Paired with half a serving of carb smart ice cream and I was good to go!! THANK YOU!!!!
Sabrina
This turned out AMAZING. I did not use the molasses and I used Swerve as my sweetener. It was a complete hit; nobody could tell it was Keto. Thank you so much for this amazing recipe!!
Jenny
Thank you so much for this recipe! It might be the best-tasting pumpkin pie I’ve ever had and I love the crust! I did have an issue with the consistency of the filling and I think it was the coconut cream substitution. I’ve never worked with coconut cream before and I bought a can from Trader Joe’s and used 1/2 cup. When it was baking it was bubbling a little and the top set with some small holes in it and the bottom crust got a little soggy. Anyway, the flavor is incredible so I’d love to hear your feedback to get it right next time. Thanks so much!
Sarah
I just pulled mine from the oven! Won’t get to taste it until tomorrow though after we’ve demished the turkey LOL it smells wonderful!
Becky
I added up carb counts on all my ingredients… And I am getting a total carb count of 24g for 12 slices.
We are counting carbs, not for blood sugar reasons, but digestive reasons.
Of course, I’ve already made the crust. Which I’ve calculated at 10.3 g per slice on its own.
You said you don’t include sweeteners in your nutrition information, but I don’t see any mention of it on any of the individual ingredients. (Packaging that is right in front of me.)
This was supposed to be a low carb treat for my husband who recently had to go very low carb. I’m making it special for him and it appears he will not be able to eat it. I was so excited about your calculation of 8g a slice but we’re at more than 3 times that -which means he can’t eat anything else all day if he eats this. Please clarify!!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Becky, Carb counts for each ingredient in our calculations comes from the USDA food database, so it will be accurate if you’re using the same ingredients. Erythritol is the sweetener in this recipe, so if you were including those carbs that is likely the difference.
McDonna
@Becky – Did you subtract the sugar alcohols *and the fiber count* to get your net carbs? If you’re counting only total carbs, then that will disqualify most any kind of recipe that contains sweetener. But for an occasional treat, sugar alcohols don’t generally cause digestive upset. It depends on the person and how healthy their digestive system is and how their body metabolizes.
I have had to research this for personal health issues and know way more about it now than I ever wanted to! The plus side is that it *does* get better!
Ruth
Just made this pie for 2018 Thanksgiving and I must say it taste just like the old pie I would make. My sweet hubby is now diabetic and he still has a sweet tooth and this pie hit it way outfield for him, home run girl, I’m so thankful. Ruth
Marie
I have the Lakanto monkfruit/erythritol blend, which is 2:1 replacement for sugar, so should I put 2/3 cup in or just 1/3 cup? I’m not sure because the 2 sweeteners you mention have different sweetness levels. And I don’t want to end up with over-sweet or too mushy pumpkin pie if I guess wrong. Thanks!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Marie, You can use the sweetener conversion calculator here.
Marie
Thanks. I know how to convert them, I wanted to know which one the listed 2/3 Cup is for. You say above the recipe that either Swerve (1:1) or Lakanto (2:1) is fine for this recipe. I made this for Thanksgiving, so I don’t remember for sure, but I think I ended up doing 1/3 Cup Lakanto. The sweetness of the pie was fine, although a bit soft, so it probably would have benefited from the added bulk of Swerve.
Wholesome Yum L
Hi Marie, for this recipe I used 2/3 cup of powdered erythritol.
Lynn
I tried this recipe with fresh pumpkin purée. I also baked it in a toaster oven. It took longer but turned out delicious baked for 70 minutes.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy to hear that, Lynn! Thank you!
Sally
Are the macros listed for the filling only, not the crust too?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Sally, The nutrition info includes both crust and filling.
Anne
Hi! I am making this recipe for the first time today and I have noticed that after baking for the full recommended time it still isn’t done in the center. My oven is brand new so it shouldn’t be the temp. Any suggestions? Otherwise it smells wonderful baking and I love the easy crust recipe!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Anne, Pumpkin pie is a custard, so it is not meant to be fully set when it’s hot out of the oven. It should be jiggly in the center, and sets more as it cools and then chills. However, all ovens are different and your pan can impact baking time as well, so it’s still possible you may need a longer baking time.
Whitney
A couple of questions: Every time I’ve made a pumpkin pie, the baking time is much closer to an hour and a half, which would definitely burn your almond flour crust even with pie shields. What causes your custard recipe to set faster? When serving, how do you remove the parchment paper from the individual slices of pie without making a big mess of the pie? I definitely want to use this recipe at Thanksgiving this year so your help is much appreciated!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Whitney, I can’t comment on other recipes, only the time that this recipe takes. A pie shield definitely works sufficiently to prevent burning the crust. As for serving, I usually cut the pie and then slide the pie server underneath between the slices and the parchment paper. The first slice is a little more difficult, but it’s easier after that. Hope you’ll make it for Thanksgiving!
Lee
DUDE.
Made this recipe yesterday- I wanted to test it out before making it for actual Thanksgiving- and I cannot even tell you how big of a hit it has been.
The crust is almost like a shortbread cookie. It’s seriously. so. good. I could eat it all by itself, and the texture is perfection. I’m thinking about making it sometime by itself and adding lemon zest to make lemon shortbread cookies.
The pie filling is totally flavorful. I usually have to add extra spices than what a recipe calls for, but your combo hits the nail on the head. The taste and texture are just like regular pumpkin pie! I did use Monk Fruit sugar instead of erythritol, and I tried your trick with fridging coconut milk and using the thick part in the place of cream. The whole thing turned out wonderfully.
Totally making this for Thanksgiving, and I’m making your pecan pie next, which I can’t wait to try.
Way to go on this one, and thank you!!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Yay, so glad to hear that, Lee! Hope your family likes the pumpkin pie just as much, and the pecan pie, too. Happy Thanksgiving!
Diane Ganda
Can you freeze the finished baked pumpkin pie?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Diane, Yes, you can!
April
Absolutely love this pumpkin pie! I’ve lost count on how many times I’ve made it. I don’t use the molasses.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I love to hear that, April! Please come back soon!
Sherry
Ok I made this filling. I didn’t use the crust recipe because I didn’t know what ghee was , just knew I didn’t have it. I used another recipe for the crust and this filling and it was really good! I’m always leery because I’ve seen low carb recipes that sound good and end up throwing the whole thing away. This was good!!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked it, Sherry! Thank you!
LynnM
So yummy! Made a trial run yesterday to see if it would be gracing our Thanksgiving meal this year (it will!), and there’s one tiny serving left. Even my non-Keto friends loved it! Thank you for another wonderful recipe!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I love to hear that, Lynn! Have a great day!
Traci
Hello! I just made this scrumptious pie! Question. I baked it for 45 min. It def seemed done, but after refrigerating, the muddle is still mushy. Is that normal? Is it undercooked? Just wondering if it’s supposed to have a slightly different texture. As long as it’s cooked, we’ll eat it, as it looks & smell ANAZING! Thank you for your awesome recipes!❤️
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked it, Traci! Thank you!
Alison
Hello, I noticed that the link to Powdered erythritol leads to Swerve. If I only have erythritol, do I have to adjust the amount since Swerve measures 1 to 1 with sugar where as erythritol does not?
Wholesome Yum L
Hi, Alison! Yes, you would need to adjust the amount since erythritol is only 70% as sweet as normal sugar and Swerve is equivalent. Check out my Keto Low Carb Sweeteners Conversion Chart to help you with your question.
Danielle Capone
How would you go about freezing this ahead of time? I’m always intimidated for some reason when it comes to freezing anything but it would save me so much time if I did! Thank you
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Danielle, You can bake the pie as directed, let it set and chill. Then, wrap it in foil and plastic wrap before placing in the freezer. Thaw in the fridge overnight.
Becky
Love this pie. Thank you. Left it out overnight is it still ok?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Becky, I don’t recommend leaving it out (it does need to be refrigerated), but personally I’d still eat it if it tastes and smells okay. That being said, I can’t be liable since usually it’s best to refrigerate, so use your best judgement. 🙂
Becky
Is coconut milk in a can considered coconut cream? How can I use can coconut milk?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Becky, They are not the same, but there is a way to use it. Place the cans of coconut cream into the fridge overnight. Open them without flipping or shaking the can. The top will be all cream, which you can then skim off. The bottom will be coconut water, so you can leave that for another use (not this recipe).
Wendy
This looks amazing!!! I’m making this tonight. I’m wondering if the nutrition information includes the crust? Thanks
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Wendy! Yes, the nutrition info includes the crust.
Wendy
Thank you…it was so good!
Gus
Normally that size can use 4 eggs, and you get 2 pies. oh, I remember it uses 2 cans of evaporated milk. Any way to change this so I can get 2 pies? thanks! oh, wait… am I thinking of a larger can?
Wholesome Yum M
Hi Gus, A 15oz can definitely only makes one pie. You can double the recipe to make 2 if you need. Enjoy!
Kari
Hi! Can I sub half and half or almond milk for the cream?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Kari, Sorry, no, half & half or almond milk will not set and thicken properly. Coconut cream should work, though.
Tammy
Maya, I LOVE your recipes. Why? Because they are delicious, I feel like I’m cheating and I’m not and they don’t make my butt big! Your the best and so is this pumpkin fall delight. I love pumpkin and I followed the recipe as is. I used melted butter instead of the ghee, almond flour, eggs and organic canned pumpkin and it was to die for. Didn’t need to use a water bath. Just kept an eye on it. This was the first pie crust I’ve ever made from scratch and it got a little overdone but I’m going to buy a pie crust protector because the foil trick didn’t work so good. Yes..I’m going to make this pie again!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you so much, Tammy!
Marie Brett
I really want to try this recipe. Can I use powdered stevia instead of erythritol? Or coconut sugar? I would prefer the stevia as it doesn’t have calories & I have it on hand. Thanks
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Marie, I haven’t tried it with either of these, but you can check the sweetener conversion calculator here for the level of sweetness. It might change the consistency though, so let me know if it works for you.
Irene
Omg this is amazing. I made this pie with the “Super Flakey Pie Crust” recipe because I’m not a fan of the crumbly consistency of the almond flour crust and it came out absolutely delicious. I should add that the quality of the pumpkin puree makes a difference. I bought some puree from Target and one from BigLots and made 2 pies, the Target one came out WAY better.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Irene!
April
What is the “Super Flakey Pie Crust” recipe you are referring to? Is it on this site and is it Keto friendly? I’m super excited to try this recipe. It sounds amazing.
Krista Clarke
This was the best low carb pumpkin pie (and crust) recipe I’ve ever tried, and I’ve tried several. I was thinking it might also be fun to make crustless pumpkin custards in individual ramekins with this recipe. Super fast and easy, and a little lower calorie (which just means eating more of it!). It was amazing, and i fed it to people who had no idea it was sugar free, and they absolutely loved it. I did try the water bath thing to keep it from cracking, but i found that it took ages to cook–I lost track of how long, I just kept extending it by 3-5 minutes until it was done. In the end the middle was still on the soft side, but it was still delicious, and I’d rather have custardy center than an overcooked pie. Perhaps I just need to play around with the timing, or skip the water bath. In any case I’ll definitely be making it again.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked the pie, Krista! Thanks for stopping by!
Dana
I had some problem getting the middle cooked. I finally used my best judgment and took it out. Still somewhat jiggly in the center, but hopefully it will cook while it rests and be just right!
Terri
OK, non-baker here so don’t laugh…. can you substitute pure pumpkin for pumpkin puree?
I love your website & recipes. I’m not much of a cook. Frankly, cooking terrifies me. But since going keto in June, I’ve lost over 30 lbs & I’m not missing any of my favorite foods thanks to your website. Everything I’ve made has been wonderful!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Terri, By “pure pumpkin” do you mean a can that says “pure pumpkin” on it, or do you mean an actual whole pumpkin? The canned stuff is the same thing as pumpkin puree. You can also use the pulp from an actual pumpkin, just puree it. I’m so glad that you like the recipes and congratulations on your progress!
Becky
Love this recipe. I made them in cupcake tins with no crust. Put it into my fitness pal and it says 12grams of carbs for one serving when this recipe hardly has any carbs. What am I calculating wrong? Used stevia instead of Erythritol and pumpkin in a can that had spices already added. Would love to eat more but until I can figure out the carbs I can’t.
Please help. Much appreciated.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Becky, It’s hard to say why it’s different without seeing the exact ingredients in MFP, but it does have wrong counts sometimes. The nutrition info on the recipe card comes from the USDA Food Database, which is the most reliable source.
Heather
The pumpkin in the can that already has spices mixed in is usually pumpkin pie filling, and has added sugar, just fyi.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Yes it does, thank you Heather!
Iwona Czarnecka
HI! Recipe looks amazing! Could I use a flax egg instead and coconut cream to make it vegan?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Iwona! Coconut cream should work fine. I haven’t tried it with a flax egg to say if that will work or not. The texture would probably be different.
Stacey Toohey
I’m excited to make this for my husband for thanksgiving. I’m going to make it 2 days in advance. Will it still be ok?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Stacey, Yes, that should be fine!
Adeline Papano-Varriale
I love your recipes! Easy and fun to cook!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Adeline!
Pri
This looks like a great recipe, thank you!
Canadian thanksgiving is this weekend, and I’m wondering if it would be fine to bake the crust a couple of days ahead of time and leave it in the fridge, and then make the filling and bake it on the day of? Or would that change the result at all?
Just trying to see how I can save a bit of time since I’ll have a lot of other dishes on the go that day.
Thanks in advance!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Pri, Happy upcoming Thanksgiving! Yes, you can definitely pre-bake the crust a couple days ahead and refrigerate.
Christine
I’ve made this twice already. Absolutely love it. Making it for the third time today. Do you know the carb amount for the molasses? I leave it out so trying to figure out what the carbs are without that. Thanks!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I’m so glad you love it, Christine! A teaspoon of blackstrap molasses has 4.67 grams of carbs, so that would reduce carbs by 0.39 grams per slice if you omit it.
Kathryn Smith
This pumpkin pie is the best dessert ever. I love it. I didn’t think something keto could ever taste so amazing. The pumpkin pie filling is so good on its own. With the crust, it’s the star of the party.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy to hear that, Kathryn! Have a great day!
Nicole
Amazing! I made this yesterday and served it for dessert… everyone RAVED! This pie is silky and delicious. I will definitely make it again and again. Thank you!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy to hear that, Nicole! Have a great day!
Carolyn
Sometimes, you’re just too tired to completely follow a recipe. Thank you, night shift. But I was making your pumpkin bread and still had pumpkin to use up. So this made the cut, sans crust. I’m sure the crust is great, but as a pumpkin custard, this rocks too. I baked it 50 minutes, the very edge was dark but it didn’t burn and may be the tastiest part. I mixed my own pumpkin pie spice to leave out the nutmeg. This is SO good!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked the pie, Carolyn! Thanks for stopping by!
BriAnna
What a great recipie! I followed the filling part exactly and it came out perfectly. Pie baked for the full 50 minutes (with foil over crust) and it was still very highly when it came out—but it set up well as it cooled.
I made my own crust using butter, a mix of coconut and almond flours, a little oil, eggs, and sweetener. Personally, I prefer a mix of flours for crusts because it tastes more like pie from when I was a kid!
Thanks Maya!
Maya | Wholesome Yum
I am so happy you liked it, Brianna! Thanks for stopping by!
Fariba
Hi Maya, can I use Swerve Icing sugar?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Fariba, Yes, you can!
Brianna
Would this turn out okay omitting the crust all together? I’m honestly not a huge fan of pie crust in general but wonder if the pumpkin mixture needs the barrier of the crust during baking?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Brianna, I haven’t tried it, but in theory it should work. Definitely line the bottom with parchment paper.
Linda Komondy
How many servings per pie?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Linda! There are 12 servings in the pie. Thanks for stopping by!
Kum
Hi! This pie is delicious. I used coconut milk and put some flax seed in the crust. I had to cook it about 15 minutes longer. Thanks for the recipe. Definitely make it again! I’m on a low carb diet by orders of my doctor. I have to stay under 100 carbs a day and it’s great to have a piece of pie (or two).
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Kum. I am happy you liked it!
Susan
Does the nutritional information include the crust? I input the crust recipe as well as the filling into MFP and the net carb count was closer to 16 g for 1/12 of a pie.
Oh, and mine also took about 20 extra minutes to not look completely liquid in the center. I even bumped my temperature up to 350F for the last 10 minutes. It came out great, though! Very tasty.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Susan, Yes, it includes the crust. MFP usually doesn’t subtract the erythritol from net carbs and that is likely why it’s showing you a high carb count. The baking time can vary a bit depending on your oven and pan, but it’s a custard so will be very jiggly when it’s done and needs to finish setting in the fridge. I’m glad you liked it!
Rose Brown
I made this twice and both times was delicious however even though I over baked by at least 10 minutes it was loose and wet in the middle. I over baked on purpose because when I took it out of the oven at 45 minutes it was clearly very wet, much wetter than normal pumpkin pie seems at that point. I know it’s supposed to be a little jiggly. I followed the recipe exactly the first time except for I used non-dairy creamer, the second time I was a little shy on powdered erythritol so I put regular cane sugar for the last couple tablespoons and that one came out even wetter in fact the crust just kind of melted into the pie. I’ve made pumpkin pie with non-dairy creamer or soy milk in the past, but with regular sugar and have not had results like this, it came out fine, so I suspected that it was the sweetener this time.
Anybody else have similar results?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Rose, I have never tried this pie with non-dairy creamer, but that is probably the issue. This recipe depends on the fat content in the heavy cream, and non-dairy creamer doesn’t have nearly as much fat. I doubt that it would set. You’d be better off trying coconut cream if you can’t have dairy heavy cream.
Rachel
I tried this recipe (using a coconut flour crust, and using the coconut creme instead of heavy cream) and it was FANTASTIC! Even the non-keto eaters liked it! Thanks for a great recipe.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Rachel! It makes me happy to hear non-keto eaters liked it! 🙂
Erica
Help! The filling isn’t setting and I’ve baked it now for over an hour. Not sure if this makes a difference, but I used granulated xylitol (missed the powdered part until it was too late), coconut cream as well as the vanilla and molasses. It’s in a 9.5 in glass pie plate. Do I just need to let it keep baking?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Erica, No, that is actually too long. It’s a custard, so it will not fully set until after you refrigerate it.
Angela
I made this pie twice for both sides of my family this year after I was diagnosed with gestational diabetes and wanted something I could eat guilt-free! It was amazing and everyone else in my family loved it, too. I’m not a baker and was nervous to make it, but it was so easy and turned out perfect! I didn’t at all feel like I was missing out! I added the vanilla, too. Thanks for the great recipe : )
Angela
I also used granulated erythritol and I thought it tasted great and had a great texture.
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Angela! I’m glad you could enjoy some pumpkin pie. 🙂
Sue
Could you use xylitol instead of erythritol? What would be the comparable amount?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Hi Sue, Yes, you can. You’d just need to powder it in a food processor for the part used in the filling. Check this sweetener conversion chart for amounts.
Kim
Can Stevia be used?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Yes! It just needs to be in powdered form.
Katrina
This looks absolutely wonderful, especially for Thanksgiving! Quick question, if I only have granulated erythritol, should I still measure out 2/3 cup and then powder it in the food processor, or will I need less than that?
Maya | Wholesome Yum
Thank you, Katrina! 2/3 cup is the amount of sweetener when powdered. So, you’d actually probably need a little more granulated erythritol to start with if you’re using that. I’m not sure about the exact amount; what I would do is measure 1 cup granulated, powder it, and then measure 2/3 cup of the powdered sweetener from that.
Amanda Grimes
I LOVE This pumpkin pie! This will be the 3rd year in a row that I make it for Thanksgiving! I don’t tell anyone it is Keto and they just think it’s a regular pumpkin pie and enjoy it! Just perfect:)